Warning: you read this at your own risk and you may collide with a wall of text. I’m sorry, but it didn’t fit in a few words.
I listened with interest to Florian’s speech at SotM 2022 (https://youtu.be/BRv-IFp_zZs), unlike him I do not feel I am a long-time contributor, although I consider myself active, both in terms of OSM editing and my activities in the Polish OpenStreetMap community. I would like to add my voice to the discussion and support Florian’s position a bit.
Let me start with why, in my opinion, the replacement of the current OpenStreetMap operating model, both in terms of the organisation and the database, is necessary. The reasons are the threats and challenges that are becoming more and more apparent and, paradoxically, stem from the growing interest in OpenStreetMap and its development.
By way of introduction, I refer you to Jennings Anderson’s speech at SotM from 2020: https://youtu.be/BI0VrPyAtcQ
and the update he made a year later and published in his diary: osm.org/user/Jennings%20Anderson/diary/396271
I’ll start with the scaremongering - here’s a list of the threats I think we will face in the near future:
Threat One - loss of community control over the project.


Evolución del mapeado en el barrio Estación de Campanillas (