SomeoneElse's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 52399788 | I'd spend a few more characters spent in the comment explaining what you're doing would be helpful, not just "found with tinyurl" (link does not load for me; presumably it needs Javascript).
|
|
| 52399788 | If you want to perform a mechanical edit on OSM data then, as pointed out previously, you need to follow osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct . You are not doing this. |
|
| 44201253 | For completeness, I fixed 117730 a while back in changeset/45037487 (the problem was unrelated to this edit, or to wikidata). |
|
| 52344210 | (re Tibshelf) as of 12 days ago it does now claim to be both a village and a civil parish; only 10 months after you added the wikidata entry to the relation.
|
|
| 52008692 | Do please ensure that you read and follow osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct before any future mechanical edits. Don't just have a bit of a chat on the talk@ list, ignore all criticism, and do it anyway. |
|
| 52341792 | You haven't addressed the places where you've added wikidata entries in error; the very first issue raised on this changeset discussion. |
|
| 52008692 | Also, the bus stop node/4942536695/history has had a wikidata link added to the network operator. Did you not do any basic sanity checking on the data your changing here (how many _bus stops_ have their own wikipedia page, seriously?) |
|
| 52008692 | Hi,
|
|
| 52002597 | Hello,
|
|
| 52388001 | The northern bit (just south of the Car park in Bilsthorpe) is a bit to the west of where the main rail lines were I think - see https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#zoom=18&lat=53.131153&lon=-1.033118 . Obviously it's a bit tricky here - bridleways and railways are linear features and here quite a width was occupied by the former railway.
|
|
| 52388001 | Hello Fingrmouse and welcome to OpenStreetMap!
|
|
| 52344210 | Here you added https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2407197?uselang=en-GB to node/598000917 (which is correct). Are you now going to remove it from relation/957593 which you did in error in changeset/44200317 which was the issue that I raised with you 10 months ago in changeset/43749373 ?
|
|
| 52384970 | Just for info - a couple of ways of seeing long distance paths like this: https://hiking.waymarkedtrails.org/#?map=12!55.9982!-2.6546 and https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#zoom=14&lat=55.99511&lon=-2.6278 . |
|
| 52341792 | That doesn't say "I'm going to add lots of links that I know are wrong", which is what is being complained about here. In particular, it doesn't address concerns raised in that thread e.g. at https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/2017-September/078756.html (incidentally similar to what I raised at changeset/43749373#map=6/53.403/-1.581 ). By automatically importing wikidata into OSM you're devaluing the work of all the OSM contributors who've taken the time to check the links that they're adding. |
|
| 52295779 | "building" is sometimes used to indicate an old phone box - node/4588450555 . |
|
| 52341792 | @nyuriks whereabouts was this mechanical edit discussed? |
|
| 52325348 | مرحبا ومرحبا بكم في خريطة الشارع المفتوح!
|
|
| 52325348 | Hello and welcome to OpenStreetMap!
|
|
| 52299954 | Thanks |
|
| 24785657 | I'm guessing that some of the tags on node/60263383/history should perhaps be adjacent rather than on the crossing? |