OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
181692301

Thank you for your response.
A Reddit thread has been pointed out to me in which you mentioned using Google Maps.
For the avoidance of doubt use of Google Maps in Openstreetmap is absolutely not allowed and any changes involving it will need to be reverted.
Cheers Phil

181692301

Hi Parkmoto
Phil from the Data Working Group with a few questions.
Where was this import discussed with the Openstreetmap community?
You should be following the import guidelines as pointed out by spiregrain.
You use the word we which suggests you are not just an individual working alone.
What explicit licence is this data released under?
Cheers Phil

181891884

This change is also bizarre as you have only removed foot and bike access but left horse as designated.

Cheers Phil

171489987

Bore da
I am very confused by this one. You have started with a footway with no access tags, on which a router will only route foot traffic. The changeset is "Not a public right of way - Eryri National Park Authority" but rather than restrict foot traffic you have allowed bikes.
What are you trying to achieve?

Diolch Phil

181891884

Hello
What legal evidence do you have that the Right of Way has been extinguished?
I can find no recent path orders for Maugersbury so please can you find evidence supported by the highway authority.
As it stands the access tags you have added and designation/prow_ref contradict each other.

Also horses are allowed but pedestrians are not?

Cheers Phil

181889466

Hello
What legal evidence do you have that the Right of Way has been extinguished?
I can find no recent path orders for Maugersbury so please can you find evidence supported by the highway authority.
As it stands the access tags you have added and designation/prow_ref contradict each other.

Cheers Phil

182962801

What is the source of this edit. A local has never seen any signs or heard of it
Have you actually been here?

177697944

Hello James
Welcome to OSM and thank you for your contribution.
A couple of pointers for the future
Roundabouts are tagged as junction=roundabout, there is no need to add oneway tags.
The spurs maintain the highway classification, they should not be tagged as _link.
Hope this is helpful.
Cheers Phil

182853988

Hi
Please add meaningful changeset comments to describe what you are doing to your fellow mappers.

osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Cheers Phil.

182158926

So your solution is to add another fake crossing?

Pedestrians can cross the road wherever they like. Drawing decorative sidewalks just adds unnecessary complications to pedestrian routing. We do not have, or want oppressive jaywalking rules.

Cheers Phil

182027902

No pedestrian actually follow this route to get from the pub to the Spar osm.org/directions?engine=graphhopper_foot&route=52.939181%2C-4.141642%3B52.939257%2C-4.141277#map=19/52.938975/-4.141400

182027902

Hello
These changesets have made pedestrian routing worse.
The pavement is only separated from the road by kerbs and a pedestrian will just cross the road, after following the normal rules. They should not be sent on a long diversion to a crossing. Especially where there are none in the real world.
Have you actually visited Tremadog and surveyed these crossings? What is the source of these crossings?
Because I can't spot them. https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=241065118038134

Cheers Phil

181772256

I am certainly no wiki expert so am not able to work out where any discussion of depreciating this tag took place or if there was any.

181772256

Thank you for your response but firstly remember that the wiki should always be taken with a large pinch of NaCl. Just because something has been written in the wiki it is not an authorisation to remove a tag from the map.

181868197

Hello beatpoet.
Phil from the Data Working Group here. Whilst OSM is a map of the world as it exists now, not as it may be in the future meaning adding proposed features is controversial, copying from copyright documents is not ok
The proposed development you have added links to a planning document with a crown copyright map. For the avoidance of doubt this is absolutely not allowed.

Cheers Phil

181772256

Why did you change them?
Have you actually visited them to observe if there are any traces or are you trying to make them appear a certain way on a particular map?

168891749

Thank you.
I have removed the alt_name tag.

Cheers Phil

174028306

Is this translation verifiable, as in is there a sign?

Cheers Phil

168891749

Thank you Charlotte
However there is no mention of Grand Central in that article.
Cheers Phil

168891749

What is the source of Grand Central which Central Station?

Cheers Phil