OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
148428377

It is rather unlikely that these roads are still 30 don't you think?

148203638

Why?
Other than my previous comments regarding one name then use the name tag.
Mapio Cymru has a maximum zoom of 16.
On OSM Carto will not start to display this node until zoom 17, then only as a dot. The name does not appear until zoom 18 which Mapio Cymru is not (yet?) capable of.

Cheers Phil

148008833

Adding English names to the name:cy tag does seem to be corrupting that tag. In openstreetmap if an object has a single name then it belongs in the name tag.

Likewise for Tesco and Burger King. So not sure what you are trying to achieve with these edits, they seem to be diminishing Welsh names rather than enhancing them.

Now if there was a law to rebrand Burger King as Burger y Brennin then I would be all for it.

Diolch Phil

148383862

Please keep your changesets to sensible areas, i.e. single countries.

This has created a large changeset with a bounding box covering most of Europe which makes it difficult for mappers to spot what has changed in their local areas.

125874815

Hi
Legal prohibitions of foot/horse/bikes are very rare in the UK.

I cannot recall any such restriction on this part of the A5 and cannot see the necessary signs of mapillary imagery.

You say Self Observered, what precisely did you observe to make this judgement?

Cheers Phil

148301432

Is there a ramp or is this only for the super fit?

Also please make your changeset comments meaningful so as to describe to other mappers what and why you are changing things.

Cheers Phil

148125376

I have completely reverted these changes in changeset/148348284

148125376

iD is not a suitable tool for reverting this number of changes. I did say we can revert these as we have experience with more powerful tools.

Please do try reverting them with iD, I am in the process of doing a revert and am working through the conflicts caused by later edits, I am trying to avoid loosing later changes.

Cheers Phil

148125376

We can revert the changes.

It is obviously possible to do your own survey of such things or add them from your own local knowledge.

Cheers Phil

148125376

Fair use of facts is an American concept. OSM is a UK organisation and in the UK we have a laws on database rights. Taking information on the scale you have from a database on this scale is not fair use. CAMRA have spent time and effort collecting these facts and under UK law this effort is protected.

148285216

Found it https://www.trapezegroup.com/

@TJ@Trapeze
You should not change OSM tagging to suit your software as that is likely to break other peoples applications.

If your software cannot use a service road then it suggests that your software is broken and needs to be fixed.

148285216

"to support upstream system" suggests this is some sort of organised edit. You may need to comply withhttps://osmfoundation.org/wiki/Organised_Editing_Guidelines

What upstream system are you refering ?to?

148125376

That would also say to me that we cannot use whatpub and I believe this, very long, list of edits require reverting/redacting.

148278156

Ok, thank you.

Phil

148278156

Hi
Access=no is still present after your edit.

Cheers Phil

147999300

Intrigued what was weird about the tagging?

148201623

Hi
way/1208820049 seems a bit odd for a bridleway. Bicycle should be yes and horse designated although the difference between yes and designated in unimportant. It shouldn't be destination.

147828927

Both OSM objects valid, one is an administrative county which provides the usual council services.
The ceremonial county still covers other things. Each should have its own wikidata and Wikipedia items, as do others in the UK.

148008833

Bore da
The name:cy tag you have added is in English, not Ysgol something?

Diolch Phil

147774219

Why have you deleted these ways which are clearly visible on aerial imagery?

Cheers Phil