OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
153173782

way/137155338 probably needs a survey.

Whilst name:cy and name:en match, name is totally different. Obviously there is a typo in the English name, should be Welsh.

But the question is really are the royal Welsh fusiliers comrades the operator and perhaps name:en should be The Red Dragon Club and name:cy and name be Clwb y Ddraig Goch.

Cheers Phil

152710790

Please split your edits so that you do not create huge bounding boxes.

The edits you make in Sheffield should be in a separate changeset to those made in Cornwall.

Cheers Phil

152647612

Hi, this edit has gone a little wrong.

I assume it is an automated armchair edit as you didn't look at the edit history or notes?
If you had you would have seen that node/11979023547 has been added in error as way/204828073/history and note/4229717would have told you.

FHRS is a useful source of postcode data for businesses already in OSM but it should not be seen as a source from which to add new objects to OSM.

Cheers Phil

152069618

Thank you

152069618

Hi
Not sure if you have surveyed this, but I know it well.
I am not convinced this fits the definition of a busway.
The first paragraph starts with "Busways are not meant to be used by motorists, pedestrians, or cyclists.". Whilst there are no entry signs there is no restriction on foot traffic and routers should not be sending pedestrians the long way round to get to the surgery.
Whilst unclassifed was a bit OTT it is just a bus station where highway=service with appropriate access would be more appropriate.
Cheers Phil

151164544

Hi, please do not tag for the renderer.
In OSM the name tag is for actual names, in this case the name of the stadium, the object mapped in OSM is Elland Road Stadium. Any other information belongs in other tags, such as operator.

Cheers Phil

151000504

Hi, what is the source of these names?

Cheers Phil

149026774

Well the spelling was correct before this and close to 200 others where tag-fiddled away, https://taghistory.raifer.tech/?#***/display/analogue

The tagging language of OSM is British English, or standard English so we should not be changing a correct spelling to American English, or Simplified English as we call it.

In my day job, as an Electronic Engineer, I would never use an Americanism such as Analog in a document.

104730770

Hi Kerr
Where exactly did you look it up?

Its just a unnamed spot height on historic OS maps.

Cheers Phil

148730502

Please make your changeset comments meaningful to inform other mappers what your intentions are.

148769324

Should we be tagging 'the law'?

It doesn't exactly need a survey.

111806991

Hi
Just wondering why you removed node/6280854138/history ?

Cheers Phil

148228217

@DaveF
> Almost all (all?) multi-track stations
> have crossovers nearby.
Not really related to this, but has become interesting this week as apparently neither Wellington nor Telford Central have crossovers nearby which is preventing Shrewsbury-Wellington or Wolverhampton-Telford trains. They can run Wolverhapton to Shifnall.

148527943

Bore da
Just wondering why you have deleted this right of way, way/1209115561/history?

Diolch Phil

148558896

Hi
Please make your changeset comments meaningful so that other mappers can see you intentions, bn v and your other comments are pretty meaningless.

Cheers Phil

125874815

The only public roads you are not allowed to walk on are motorways and where specifically signed.

https://assets.digital.cabinet-office.gov.uk/media/55b8bd6fe5274a151e000015/Information-sign-start-motorway.jpg
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/8f/UK_traffic_sign_625.1.svg/80px-UK_traffic_sign_625.1.svg.png

I assume you are talking about the roads in Warwickshire in this case? Although imho the rights of way make a far nicer walk :)

Cheers Phil

125874815

Thank you.

All roads and paths are highways :)

And the A5 is a very a very ancient one. Removing highway rights is generally no done. We have a saying "Once a highway always a highway" which was coined in 1921. Roads with restricted access are mostly new builds which have never had foot/bicycle/horse access rights.

Cheers Phil

125874815

Thank you.
To the east there is a path cyclists and pedestrians, but any router worth its salt will choose this over the road, but to the west there is no alternative. A pedestrian will choose the verge obviously.

In OSM we map legal access restrictions, not what we think are dangerous.

These restrictions should be removed.

Cheers Phil

148351759

Hi Greg
Diolch for your edits on Ynys Môn, however in this and your other changesets you have tagged buildings a landuse=farmyard. This tag should only be used on the outer boundary of a farmyard.

Please could you correct this and bear in mind in the future.

Diolch Phil

148421488

Hi
Something has gone very wrong, you have added strange tags (man_made=planter material=shea butter) to many objects spanning two continents. I am not sure what your intentions were but this is not good.

Maybe try using iD as a beginner and keep to reality in a smaller area.

I have reverted this changeset.