trigpoint's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 83828992 | Hi, welcome to OSM. In OSM we add what exists in real life, please do not add test data. The description 'to be planted' suggests that this is not yet a wood so plrobably shouldn't be mapped as one. The name NRN looks odd, the name field is for actual names and abbreviations are rarely names of woods. Please only add what really, exists and please remember that OSM is a live database. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83782916 | Hi, welcome to OSM.
Cheers Phil |
|
| 83542786 | No response so have reverted and redid the good bits. Changeset was too big to pick through. |
|
| 83751275 | Hi, thank you for your edit however it has gone a little wrong and I have reverted it. Shrewsbury School was already correctly mapped, it is not one big building. Please continue to map but only add things that exist in real life. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83542786 | Hi, welcome to OSM. This is very big for a first edit. Please try to keep them smaller. I am not sure what you mean by fix me requests, but if you means suggestions made by the iD editor, then they do need to be reviewed individually as the suggestions are often not the correct thing to do. A few issues I have found.
M & S, H & M and Smiths are not individual buildings, the buildings forming Pride Hill were mapped correctly after much survey work. Greenhous was mapped as an area, that was correct. It is not all a single building. Drive-through=no is not needed on banks, do they even exist outside the US? way/350314934 is part of Rea Brook, but the name should not be put onto the riverbank, the tagging was correct. way/52280910 was still a construction site 3 weeks ago and as all building work has stopped then it probably still is. Hazeldine Court is on the ground, it should not have level=1 on it. What is the source of the screens at Cineworld? Please take care mapping and check each tag that is being changed, Please add new stuff, but keep you changes small. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83535542 | Hi, welcome to OSM. Thank you for your edit however I am always a bit concerned when a new mapper begins by deleting a large number of existing objects. Please continue to map, but try to add new objects and please look at and consider the warnings generated by the editor, such as crossing buildings. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83486181 | HI, Black Lodge Brewing was already mapped. I have removed your duplication. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83477602 | Hi, welcome to OSM and thank you for your edit. Just one small thing, the name tag in OSM is used for actual names, Former Royal Mail Sorting Office is a description of what it used to be. Until it becomes something else, the name tag in this case should be removed.
Cheers Phil |
|
| 83445797 | And make them meaningful. Data Change is not helpful. |
|
| 83280779 | Hi, what source did you actually use for this edit?
Cheers Phil |
|
| 83368275 | Hi, what evidence do you have to change this to a track? Imagery and usage doesn't suggest that to me. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83080862 | I would include the community name to be clear so prow_ref="Llanrug 75" Cheers Phil |
|
| 83271335 | There is only one single on the ground object, Shropshire Council and Unitary authority are exactly the same thing. Q21694759 is a duplication that appears to have been created by someone who lacked any short of on the ground knowledge. |
|
| 83271335 | Why have you changed this? The orignal wikidata tag was accuarate and you seem to have replaced it with a duplicate.The admin area Shropshire is the Shropshire Council area. Please revert this edit. Cheers Phil |
|
| 81735204 | Hi
Cheers Phil |
|
| 83074771 | Thank you
<rant at iD>The feature of iD where it suggests fixes to objects that the mapper has no direct interest in was a very poor decision and really should be considered a mechanical edit</rant> Cheers Phil |
|
| 83074771 | Hi, thank you for your edit.
You do seem to have changed other stuff, have you reviewed each of these or are these blind edits based on iD suggestions? For example you have changed way/523111898/history from a footway to a path, why? Also you have added the tag public_transport=station to Leicester North, which is a heritage line and not public transport. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83088313 | Certainly not a furniture shop either, its a big barn place that sells almost anything and changes with the seasons. I tend to go with shop=variety but will fix it later Cheers Phil |
|
| 83054173 | Thank you for changing this, however you have not restored the buildings which you had removed the tags from. When starting to map it is always better to map the places that you know, and look at the changes you have made. We all make mistakes but by looking at the area we quickly learn and fix them. We do need to revert all of your changes, iD is not able to do this, please do not make any further edits in the UK. Cheers Phil |
|
| 83051389 | Thank you for the explaination, but please remember we are not allowed to use Google to obtain information.
Cheers Phil |