ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 109564517 | Please don't put address information in the name key, there are separate addr:housenumber and addr:street that should be used instead. See addr=*
|
|
| 109294632 | Correct action is to tag as access=private to mark legal access, not delete the trace. access=private |
|
| 109235140 | Please use meaningful changeset comments: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments Do you have a source for this manor? A name?
|
|
| 109294632 | Why have you deleted way 411173270? It is visible in the aerial imagery you refer to
|
|
| 109328059 | This changeset has marked a huge portion of O'Farrells Track as a culvert, I suspect what you wanted to achieve would be tagging the portion of the stream that passes under the track with tunnel=culvert and layer=-1
|
|
| 108776687 | Without local knowledge I cannot determine if the building is entirely used for sanitary purposes or if the tag just represents a toilet in a building. |
|
| 108470262 | This is not supported by the imagery and appears to be vandalism. Reverting
|
|
| 108450719 | The new builds appear to be visible in the Bing, ESRI and Maxar imagery which is available i the Id editor. Just beware that the imagery mat itself be offset, not sure how to correct for that in Id, easy in JOSM
|
|
| 107970691 | You have tagged the roof as flat but from the LINZ aerial imagery it appears to be hipped whilst the adjacent roof is flat
|
|
| 107989967 | You have tagged a forest polygon with name=Main Road, is this really the name of the forest? What is the source for this?
|
|
| 107980446 | Vandalism, reverted
|
|
| 107980615 | Vandalism, reverted
|
|
| 107853530 | You've put a Cafe name on the moving walkway object, instead you should create a new node tagged amenity=cafe and name=Pier Cafe
|
|
| 107573538 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. A few points: 1) Please use meaningful changeset comments "map updates" is too generic, see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments. 2) Please limit changesets to a smaller geographic area, this one spanned from Turkey to New Zealand which makes QA difficult. 3) Be careful of dragging nodes, you've moved the address node for 21 Ventnor Street, Seatoun onto the street way
|
|
| 107528527 | Name should presumably be "The Frameless Glass Company" and not the generic "Head Office", see name=* Also there probably be some sort of entity tagging, perhaps "office=company"? osm.wiki/Tag%3Aoffice%3Dcompany
|
|
| 98265002 | Please don't put descriptions like "Great view" in the name field - name=*
|
|
| 99405963 | Please don't put descriptions like "only by boat" in the name tag, there is a dedicated description tag for this
|
|
| 107408139 | There is no need to add a node as well as the building way - this has resulted in two objects for the entity. Rather just add any tags that were missing to the existing way.
|
|
| 107375028 | Please do not delete objects just because they are private access - if they physically exist they can be mapped and tagged with access=private (as the footway was) to designate the legal access rights. See access=*
|
|
| 107233890 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. A quick pointer: many buildings in NZ consist only of 90 degree corners. You can enforce this in the Id editor by selecting the outline, right clicking and choosing "Square" (shortcut "Q").
|