Hi, again,

I saw that several name:* tags were removed. Could you explain why those were deleted?

Thanks.

Hi,

I noticed that the name tag for this river was changed from "Грузька" to "река Грузская". Could you please clarify the reasoning behind this change?

Also, I saw that several name:* tags were removed. Could you explain why those were deleted?

Thanks.

Thanks for your reply, PA_Barre

Could you please correct it?

And of course renaming to "Piatra-Neamț" ...

Hello,

may we know the reason behind removing the following tags here?
wikidata=Q20429820
wikipedia=ro:Gara Piatra Neamț

Thanks.

Hello,

may we know the reason behind removing wikidata=Q20429820 and wikipedia=ro:Gara Piatra Neamț ?

Thanks.

I agree that identical names across languages may be redundant. However, the removed tags included established exonyms (e.g. documented in sources such as Wikipedia), which are not identical to the default name and therefore not redundant.

OSM names are based on verifiable usage. As no sources have been provided showing that these names are not in use, their removal does not appear to be in line with OSM guidelines. If no supporting sources can be provided, I would consider restoring the removed names.

Best regards

Thanks for your reply.

The removal of identical or unverified transliterations may be justified. However, OSM tagging is based on verifiable usage rather than whether a name is considered "translatable".

In addition, names in other languages (including exonyms) should be kept if they are in established use and supported by reliable sources. Could you please provide sources showing that these names are not in use? If not, I would suggest reconsidering the removal, as it may be appropriate to restore them.

Best regards

Hello, again,

this changeset removes a large number of multilingual name tags across many objects.

Could you please explain:
- What source or guideline was used for these deletions?
- Why multilingual names were removed instead of preserved?

Thank you.

Hello, again,

this changeset removes a large number of multilingual name tags across many objects.

Could you please explain:
- What source or guideline was used for these deletions?
- Why multilingual names were removed instead of preserved?

Thank you.

Hello, again,

this changeset removes a large number of multilingual name tags across many objects.

Could you please explain:
- What source or guideline was used for these deletions?
- Why multilingual names were removed instead of preserved?

Thank you.

Hi,

may we know the reason behind removing: name:de, name:fa, name:ml, name:sr, name:cs, name:hu?

node/130484930/history/37

Thanks.

Hi,

may we know the reason behind renaming the river from "Fiume Platani" to "c"?

way/306401118/history/40

Thanks.

@MappingMore Thanks for fixing the mentioned issue and for commenting.

Would it be possible to add a direct link to the changeset instead of only the raw changeset ID? Something like changeset/180232285 would be very helpful.

Thanks!

@MappingMore Thanks for fixing the mentioned issue and for commenting here.

Would it be possible to add a direct link to the changeset instead of only the raw changeset ID? Something like changeset/180133797 would be very helpful.

Thanks!

@MappingMore Thanks for fixing the mentioned issue and for commenting here.

Would it be possible to add a direct link to the changeset instead of only the raw changeset ID? Something like changeset/180232285 would be very helpful.

Thanks!

Hi Vibha_Lakra,

Could you please share the reason for removing and only partially remapping the natural=water reservoir in this changeset?

Thanks in advance!

Hello,

this changeset removes a large number of multilingual name tags (name:ru, name:pl, and in some cases even name:uk) across many objects.

Could you please explain:
- What source or guideline was used for these deletions?
- Why multilingual names were removed instead of preserved?

Thank you.

Partly reverted by changeset/180171064

Mhm