ffmp's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 186971491 | 1. About adding fake names: I never used mapy.com/freemap.sk, but mapy.com allows to add photos to arbitrary place, even without OSM entity. For example: https://mapy.com/en/turisticka?source=osm&id=1040698144&sourcep=foto&idp=3919240&x=45.5003272&y=42.3957546&z=15&ovl=2
2. About absent bridges: yes, quality of map for Georgia is relatively poor. It's ok to map places using satellite/orthophoto images and it's ok to improve/fix a priori wrong data, even to not-totally-correct state, but here new wrong entities were added (I checked history), so I'm asking, how this happened to determine whether similar mistakes possible and to fix it. 3. About zoo: big dogs, that defend sheeps/territory, is known problem for hikers in whole Tusheti, but this cannot be reason for adding zoo point. OSM used not only by hikers. Imagine for example if somebody asks AI chatbot 'How many zoos are in Georgia/Caucasus?'. Propose to delete zoo for now. Possibly OSM needs something similar to angry_dog tag, but in case of Tusheti we will neeed to mark half of the region with such tag) |
|
| 186971491 | Thank you for verbose response. 1. Adding name tag to entities without name close to osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer, IMHO.
2. About absent (I said nothing about destroyed) bridges:
3. About zoo: I don't know what object there, so can't propose better-fitting tag. Whether this is just shepherds house with dogs, guarding nearby territory? |
|
| 187792865 | For history see:
|
|
| 187690561 | Some village names was edited in this and my next changesets:
|
|
| 186971491 | Hello, some questions:
|
|
| 184749765 | Return previous name in changeset/187668706 |
|
| 184749765 | Why 'Охкури' was changed to 'Оххури'?
|
|
| 184748686 | I've fixed 'name:en'.
|
|
| 184749659 | Sorry, but where did you find such names (especially name:ge)?
|
|
| 186250342 | I've reverted this changeset (see changeset/186563009). Let's check thoroughly, before submitting such massive changes. |
|
| 186250342 | The problem not with naming, but with locations of the points. There are no passes *at all* at places, where you marked it. Check topo maps (i.e. with height levels) for example. More examples:
2. Okrila (node/14042104663) with height 3100m placed near the river on the height ~1800m. NB: guess, there is mistake in caucatalog also. As I can see on photo there Оксана/"Oksana" pass was meant (which must me somewhere near Khazny glacier relation/8083105). 3. pass '46th army' (node/14042106294) have meaningful 'name' tag, but obviously wrong names on other languages (and even 'name:ru' tag). Location also wrong. In fact, I'm unable to find at least one correct point. How did you do this changes? You specified source as 'survey'. According to OSM wiki "This means the author was physically nearby the object", but you edited 373 passes, I'm doubt, that you were near all of them. BTW, changeset message is "Added label in other languages ...", so editing of existing points is expected, but (almost) all points are the new one. |
|
| 186250342 | Didn't check all changes, but possibly even safer to revert whole changeset. |
|
| 186250342 | At least some of passes here have absolutely wrong locations.
1. Nenskra Zapadny (node/14042104639) 2. Shirokoe sedlo (node/14042106265) 3. Nakhsvi (node/14042106208) |
|
| 184753673 | One relation is better. I meet relation:street for the first time, so avoid editing.
|
|
| 185704739 | Thanks, don't know, how can I miss this. Possibly because .tm is top-level-domain for Turkmenistan. |
|
| 181397368 | Hello, seems this changeset is wrong. See
|
|
| 181362737 | Deleted addr:street tags contained wrong info, so I have right to delete it.
This is good example of why relation better, than addr:street on each building. |
|
| 145649977 | Hello, JOSM complains on relation/16895285:
I don't understand, what did you want to draw here and why need to map simple rectangular building as multipolygon. Fix this JOSM error please. |
|
| 177832068 | Was wrong date in message.
|
|
| 175670146 | I returned street names for buildings, that have it before my changes as promised. Still decide to leave these buildings inside relations.
|