Sammyhawkrad's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 168527183 | Hi BigKev97, that's a name, not a date, so changing it to match a date format is incorrect. Your changes have been reverted by changeset/179707497 |
|
| 179194320 | Hi Kingenious, welcome to OSM. Please use Title Case for names instead of BLOCK LETTERS. |
|
| 178605297 | I'm glad you realise your mistake now. As I mentioned earlier, there are neighbourhoods within these suburbs that are yet to be mapped.
|
|
| 179168008 | Hi Godfred_uew, it seems you enjoy using UPPER CASE a lot, but note that this is against OSM convention. You can look everywhere else on the map and notice that you are the only one doing that. The name=* tag should always be in the title case except for acronyms. |
|
| 178853883 | Hi adam@1234, welcome to OSM. Note that most, if not all, major roads are already mapped. Before you map a road, check whether one already exists. The name=* tag is for official road names. Avoid using tags you don't understand yet. |
|
| 178753243 | Hello Aliu_Paul, don't add amenity=school to every building. There is one amenity=school polygon mapped for the entire school, and that should be enough.
|
|
| 178729719 | Hi NACHINDI _ ABDUL _RAUF, you request a review for every changeset, but you don't heed the feedback. You should map each building separately; mapping a cluster of buildings as a single unit is not good practice. |
|
| 178302222 | Somehow, your reply notification landed in my spam, and I'm only seeing this now. There is no doubt that there were errors in those changes you reverted. I have fixed several of them after restoring the changes, and I agree way/1475246797 is not correctly mapped. It's not a path I would add to the map, and I believe it is okay to delete it outright.
My concern was that it's better to fix the mistakes than to erase valuable information that came along with them. |
|
| 178694814 | Hello NACHINDI _ ABDUL _RAUF, map each building separately. Mapping a cluster of buildings as single buildings is not proper mapping. |
|
| 178605297 | Once again, my apologies. I had no intention of spamming you; it just turned out I had further concerns after submitting a comment. |These are streets with street names that do not allow vehicle traffic, versus simple footpaths.|
| Footpaths often do not get rendered downstream |
|Deleted church: Pls identify via node id|
|suburbs vs neighborhoods - pls look at the definition for each|
| As an example - La is definitely a suburb, places like Ringway Estates, North Ridge and Asylum Down are NOT. |
|A cluster of "suburb" nodes will only render one node in almost ALL downstream clients.|
|Building=part has to be in a relation for it to be valid|
| I don't map for a specific downstream client, so I'm not "mapping for the renderer" - I'm just trying to make sure that these areas and districts actually show up!|
|
|
| 178605297 | I'm sorry, but the more I look into this changeset, the more issues I find. Although valuable street names have been added, it will be a pain to nitpick and fix the data damage introduced in this changeset. I believe reversing this changeset would be the best solution. As a non-local, why do you downgrade suburbs to neighbourhoods? And why do you remove details of the transport network relations? |
|
| 178605297 | I notice that you've also deleted a church; any reason for that? |
|
| 178605297 | Hello Greg_Rose, you've added a number of footpaths here with the tag highway=pedestrian. I think highway=footway or highway=path would be more suitable. |
|
| 178625439 | Hello, kindly desist from deleting addresses or anything you don't have sufficient knowledge of. This changeset has been revert via changeset/178628272 |
|
| 178577107 | Hello, don't add made-up names to roads or any other object. "road link to a village" is not a name. Tag the polygons around settlements with landuse=residential instead of place=*. |
|
| 178481523 | A post office box address is not a postcode. I'll advise you stop adding "addr:postcode"="P.O.BOX 19" to all the objects you map. |
|
| 178481704 | Hi Godfred_uew, you have added EMRYSTECH SOLUTION two times. Which is the correct location? The names of places should not be ALL UPPER CASE; using Title Case is the acceptable practice in OSM. |
|
| 178465531 | Hi FLPREKO, avoid adding generic names to show what an object is. The name=* tag is used for recognised or official names. Change building=yes to building=school to denote that it's a school building. I will remove those in this changeset, but take note for future edits. |
|
| 178431616 | Hi MagnusQuaye, you don't have to save/upload after mapping a single building. It's much better to map several buildings and upload them in one changeset. |
|
| 178350949 | Hi St_Boniface, welcome to OSM and thanks for the contributions so far. A few things you need to know:
|