Hello shemeshi,

Thank you for your contributions to OSM!

Please elaborate on why this pond does not exist. Is it dry, was it destroyed, or is it something else?

Thanks!

כמו שכתבתי, בזמן שיצרתם נקודה חדשה, כבר הייתה נקודה עבור "שני לבנה"

יש כלל חשוב במיפוי ב OSM:

osm.wiki/Good_practice#One_feature,_one_OSM_element

גם אם לאותו מקום יש מספר שמות, אין לייצר לו כפילויות. לכן אתם מתבקשים לחפש ולעדכן אלמנטים שקיימים כבר ב OSM לפני שאתם מוסיפים כפילויות.

המיקום של נקודת שם, עבור יישוב או כל יישות אחרת, לא צריך להיות בהכרך במרכז, אלא להתחשב בשאר חלקי המפה. למשל, המיקום של "ישראל" לא נמצא במרכז הארץ אלא צפפונית מערבית לבאר שבע.

אם מסיבות כאלו יש לדעתכם צורך לתקן את המיקום של נקודת שם, בבקשה להזיז את הנקודה הקיימת ולא ליצור כפילות.

Hello Gábor,

Actually, it is the over-simplicity of the lock tag that bothered me.

I now see that in February of 2024, the wiki page for the foot tag was changed such that "For a barrier, crossing, entrance and ford=yes, it indicates there is physical access, in the case there is a sign that should be used instead." A similar phrase now also exists in the bicycle tag page.

As far as I can see now, both GraphHopper and OSRM, when using the foot profile, treat the foot=yes tag as overriding the locked=yes tag.

I therefore withdraw my request for deleting the lock tag.

I do wonder if this gate physically blocks bicycles, or if bikers can physically get around or over it.

Thanks,
Zeev

שלום Yanivdu

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM!

בעריכה זו הוספת גם את השביל הזה
way/1238506380
שעוקף חלק ממעלה חצרה.

השבוע ההיתי בשטח ולא ראיתי סימנים של שביל שם.

way/1125886400 had a name in version 1

See https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/1125886400

@yrtimiD,

The settlement does not exist any more, as can also be seen in the Wikipedia article linked by the original mapper.

https://he.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%A0%D7%A6%D7%A8%D7%99%D7%9D

Also see, osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_historic_events_and_historic_features

Hello LockOnGuy,

Thank you for your contributions to OSM!

Please avoid adding historic elements that do exist any more.

See
osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_historic_events_and_historic_features

Hello OmerMadlan and the Madlan research department,

Thank you for your long-time contributions to OSM!

In this edit you have added an address node
node/12745185689
while address was already mapped by
way/236874285

There are several similar comments on your edits:
https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=16445085

From the outside, it looks like the discussed edits are adding node addresses and places regardless of the existing mapping.

Such changes, and the lack of response on your part give raise to a question if this account is used for automatic edits, potentially importing data from an unidentified source.

Please refrain from further edits and contact the local Israel community to discuss these seemingly automated edits through the OSM forum for Israel: https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/il/50

More information on automated edits can be found at osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct

Best regards,
Zeev

Shani Livne was already mapped by node/1080455114

This changeset was reverted in changeset/164486601

Hello GBAB,

Thank you for your map updates in Israel!

In this edit, you have added a swing gate:
node/11992417684

It seems like some routing engines, like OSRM, effectively treat the lock=yes tag as an overriding access=no, and ignoring the foot=yes tag. The result is that no traffic can go through the barrier, not even pedestrians.

OSRM:
https://map.project-osrm.org/?z=17&center=32.847582%2C35.509808&loc=32.849713%2C35.508102&loc=32.845903%2C35.510205&hl=en&alt=0&srv=1

Would you mind if I remove that tag?

Best regards,
zstadler

Could you specify which OSM way you are referring to?

שלום דודי_אלון,

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM!

בעריכה זו מיפית את
way/1353173369
ותייגת אותו כדרך ברוחב 3 מטר אם איסור כניסה לרכב.

תוכל בבקשה הלבהיר מה הגורם לאיסור הכניסה הזה?

תודה,
זאב

The earlier gate is at an inaccurate location.
See node/12632532847/history/1#map=19/31.785507/35.457170&layers=D

@SafwatHalaby,

Either way is fine as a means to have a discussion with the community.

I also prefer the community forum for such discussions, as it also allows non-Israeli contributors to participate.

Please start that discussion at
https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/il/50

Hello

Such edits are considered "bulk edits" and should be discussed in advance with the community.
Even if you mapped most, if not all, of the buildings, they are now part of the map.

Since the discussion was not done in advance, I would like to ask you to join the discussion in the [OSM_Israel telegram channel](https://t.me/OSM_Israel)
or open a new discussion in the [OSM Israel community](https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/il/50)
Thanks,
Zeev

שלום Izzy Katz,

תודה על תרומתך למיפוי ב OSM

על פי כללי המיפוי הנהוגים בארץ, אנא השתמש בתגית mtb:name לשמות של סיגנלים ולא בתגית name.

תודה,
זאב

Hi,

The use of access=restricted is unclear and [considered a mistake](access=*?uselang=en#Possible_tagging_mistakes) by the wiki

What is the actual restriction for
way/1173069168
way/1173069171
way/1173069172
way/1151952295

Hello Sokuya,

Thank you for your huge contribution to the OSM mapping in Israel!

In this edits you have changed the "building:levels" tag of way/400664395 from 7 to 1.5

The wiki at
building:levels=*?uselang=en#Values says:
"Values should be a positive integer number. Fractional values (like 1.5) are not valid (what is the meaning of a 0.5 floor?) "
The wiki also describes how to provide height in meters.

There seem to be several other buildings tagged with non-integer "building:levels" values.

Best regards,
Zeev

Hello KlausG,

In this edit, the building:levels tag of way/56318646 was set to a non-integer value: "."

See https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/56318646

Best regards,
zstadler

שלום
GorALexeY

תודה על התרומה שלך למיפוי ב
OSM
והתמונות שאתה מוסיף, במיוחד!

התמונה שהוספת לפני שנה לתצפית הזו היא תמונה שנוספה לפני 5 שנים לתצפית אחרת.

node/1062326219/history/3