OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
180727387

once again reverted. Do not delete the way way/190595192 , it's part of several relations.

Is this what you've been trying to do?
changeset/180734493

180727662

partly reverted - the parking space is there, it's confirmed

172414535

Попробовал применить, чего в вики написано для service=alley:

In some regions, chiefly in Europe, narrow streets in historic cities that provide access to the main entrances of buildings may also be mapped as alleys, distinguishing them from wider modern streets mapped, for example, as highway=residential. In some areas, this case is much more common than the rear access case.

Ибо классических alley с задней стороны домов в Грузии нет (ну м. б. кроме разве что в каких-то новостроенных коттеджных посёлках). Для старой хаотичной застройки с узкими улочками, где не хватит места для разъезда двух машин или для объезда припаркованной машины, имхо, описание alley как выше вполне применимо, ибо имеем вполне себе historic city.

180684231

Was moving this node intentional or not? node/6893244149

180678731

Hi! I've reverted your edits since you had deleted the way way/190595192 — it's used only for buses (access=no, psv=designated) and is a member of several relations for bus routes. Please redo you changes without deleting that way

180624712

reverted — the property location is definitely wrong, please find out the exact location before adding in to the map

180624416

reverted — the property location is definitely wrong, please find out the exact location before adding in to the map

180624350

reverted — the property location is definitely wrong, please find out the exact location before adding in to the map

180630152

reverted - it's not separate from the street

changeset/180641748

180474984

fitness_station, I guess?

180227996

1. I also assume that separate relations for lanes & dead-ends are better...

2. I would put it this way: all the data that is *really* used by consumers and changes the way the map is rendered (or the way searching works) should stay as ways' tags. Names are vital, in all the languages; old names, if they are still used by the populace or if they are still present on some other maps (like the shitty Google), should also stay in order to make searching by them possible. Old names from Russian Empire or early Soviet times are all in all just a piece of interesting information, so it's better not to clutter each segment with them.
Wikidata, etymology & similar tags... Well, they are indeed used by some consumers (like Organic Maps), but in the end they also only serve to provide some interesting information, nothing more. A good consumer which strives to provide such information to a user should parse street relations. In this case, IMHO, a one-to-one correspondence between a wikidata entity and an OSM entity takes precedence, so only the relation should keep such tags.

180332688

"a kindergarden can have a main entrance (if there are many entrances) or a separate service entrance" — yup, if it's building=kindergarten. Here it's building=residential (apartments, de facto), with at least four entrances: one main, one secondary, one which I'm not sure about but my guess is that it's to a private apartment, and one to kindergarten. Some type should be assigned to it; if you have any other suggestions beside plain "yes", don't keep them to yourself.

And no, as long as we have entrance=shop etc., I see no reason to engage into any discussions about new values.

180332688

"the type of the entrance" — precisely, and we need to distinguish between different kinds of entrances here. As can bee seen from https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/?key=entrance#values , there are widely used values "shop", "office" & "restaurant"; so yes, the differentiation is commonly used basing on the type of services. In this case it's a kindergarten in an apartment building; if you can suggest another, more generic value that would suit this case, it may do.

"Why are you running a revert before any discussion?" - likewise, I can ask why are you fixing something that isn't broken.

180332688

reverted - tag "entrance" can have any needed value, "shop", "hotel" or in this case "kindergarten", to differentiate it from the main entrance to the apartment building

changeset/180342115

180258125

reverted with respect to the Embassy of Hungary: it's two houses to the west, node/4910507221 , don't believe google

180227996

fixed that
changeset/180239149

180227996

Hi! For Ingorokva & Leonidze Streets, there are relations relation/18626628 & relation/18621666 , name:etymology and similar tags should go there. (For the other streets with more that one segment, similar relations should ultimately be created and likewise populated by any tags that are not descriptive of a particular segment, except the vital name:xx tags).

179819421

reverted with respect to roundabout: it has to be split into parts due to bus route relation/15348534

changeset/179822805

179639340

https://maps.gov.ge/map/portal is the official source for street names. To view them, in the left menu select სამისამართო >
სამისამართო მონაცემები . Only is cases when there are street signs that are newer than the information in the cadastre, should the names from those street signs be used.

Do you have a photo of a street sign with such a name?

179701341

rv - both companies are already mapped; please don't use custom tag values. building=commercial is valid, building=ქვის_მაღაზია is not; surface is used for roads & paths, like surface=asphalt

changeset/179714570