OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
124040656

Hi, I am baffled as to why you have added use_sidepath here? On mapillary I cannot see any signs prohibiting pedestrians or cyclists on this road so wondering what your sources are?

Cheers Phil

125118344

Sorry, found it further back. There would normally be a sign at the junction.

Cheers Phil

125118344

Hi, just wondering what sources you have use for this turn-restriction?

There are no signs visible om mapillary so I I wondering how you have concluded that there is a restriction here?

Cheers Phil

124808422

Hi
Wondering why you have changed some footways to paths?

Path is a problematic tag in England/Wales due to access rules. Footway implies foot only, which along with designation=public_footpath is correct. The problem with path it needs a load of access tags to be meaningful. Many applications will assume that cycling is allowed oh highway=path, unless it is tagged as bicycle=no which then results in illegal routing decisions made by some apps (komoot spings to mind).

Cheers Phil

125144364

Hi
SJ 269413 is not a ref. It is an OS grid reference which is just a location which can also be derived from the OSM location,

Cheers Phil

125146177

Hi
Whilst these may not be the most sensible manoeuvres, they are not actually illegal. There are no signs prohibiting U turns here.
What sources have you used?

Cheers Phil

125028321

Sorry I was a bit quick, and glad you had a 'fun' walk.

Cheers Phil

125028321

Hi
Tagging marker=yes doesn't make a lot of sense. What is the marker?

Cheers Phil

124896240

Operator:type=private seems an odd way to describe The National Trust is it not.

Cheers Phil

124781543

Should there not be a weight limit?

Cheers Phil

124649529

I don't, sorry

124575515

Hi, the campsite is already mapped.

I have removed the duplication.

Cheers Phil

124575643

Hi, the campsite is already mapped.

I have removed the duplication.

Cheers Phil

124604720

Hi, the pub is already mapped.

I have removed the duplication.

Cheers Phil

124604760

Hi, the cafe is already mapped.

I have removed the duplication.

Cheers Phil

124549040

Hi Joris
Thank you/diolch.

Phil

124549040

Hi, when changing access tags in Cymru/England please be careful not to break existing routing.

For example by adding access=private to way/229617291 you have broken foot access to the right of way which is obvious to someone familiar with access rules in Cymru/England as a footway connects further along.

The tagging of the right of way is far from perfect but please look for such subtleties. Maybe motor_vehicle=private would be a better tag or as the service way leads to a farm building then driveway isn't the correct tag.

Cheers Phil

124410961

I have removed foot=no from these roads.

Cheers Phil

124410961

Since when have pedestrians been prohibited from the A500.

I travelled along it last weekend and no new signs had appeared.

124362673

Thank you, I realise that is the way it works but isn't the idea of phone apps to map objects you are standing in front of rather than to map places you have visited in the past?