OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
177282055

Hi,
"survey:avg_speed:kmh" is not used in any other place.
The tag "average_speed" is already rarely in use and could be used here as well.

177414433

Please check your edits. It's "building", not "buildng".

177460916

Please check your edits. It's "building", not "biulding".

177307489

Hi,
winter_sports=yes is not a common tag.
Maybe seasonal=winter would be a better choice?

177241292

Hallo,
du fügst hier sehr viele Tags hinzu bei denen der Wert merkwürdige Texte enthält, z.B.

intermittent = yes # falls saisonal

Außerdem gibt es einige Tags die es sonst nirgends gibt, z.b.

source_of_water = groundwater # oder aquifer, falls bekannt

Das sieht mir sehr nach ungeprüften Hallizunationen von einer KI aus...

177264091

Hi,
is the tag you added for a zone of parking tickets?

You can check the wiki for the proper tag:
osm.wiki/Street_parking

I guess it is

parking:both:zone = orange

177276274

Hi,
I found several date tags here:

artwork:creation_year
date
start_date

That's not really common. What is the intended meaning of them?

177179224

What is the source of these edits? I can't find any hint that these objects actually exist.

177199745

Schau doch mal ins Forum, da wird genau das gerade beredet: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/fahrbahn-uberquerungsstellen-mit-kombination-aus-abgesenkten-und-nicht-abgesenkten-bordstein/99940

177206994

Hi,
please check the gas stations you edited: "fuel:fuel:diesel:class2" is a mistake and should be "fuel:diesel:class2"

177338695

Hi,
you added 'catenary_mast:support' here. Shouldn't that be "catenary_mast:supporting"?

177177976

I don't know how good the automatic translation is, but to me it sounds like you really need to sign up and it's not just "touch and go" like, e.g. in some public transport systems.
Maybe tagging it like this:

authentication:none:conditional = yes @ (Mo-Th 08:00-17:00; Fr,Sa 08:00-18:00; Su 08:00-13:00)

authentication:mobile_phone = yes

authentication:membership_card = yes

opening_hours = Mo-Th 08:00-17:00; Fr,Sa 08:00-18:00; Su 08:00-13:00 || 24/7 open "with login / id chip"

self_checkout:conditional = only @ 24/7; no @ (Mo-Th 08:00-17:00; Fr,Sa 08:00-18:00; Su 08:00-13:00)

177132348

Hi,
I think that there are several issues with the tags as they are. Maybe you can write a draft and put it up for discussion in the forums.

- "est:" is not used in any other context. It makes things rather complicated for both mappers and data users - they need to support tags with and without prefix and there is no clear rule when the prefix is needed. If it's an estimate can be part of the source tag. (I know there is "est_width" but it has never been properly defined in the 20 years of use and was a bad idea from ancient times IMHO)

- the "source_area" doesn't need to be tagged, this is a property of the object itself

- "stem_count" doesn't need a new tag, "tree_count" is already in use. (maybe "

- "avg_spacing" is not needed, this can be calculated from the area and the number of trees

- for the size of crowns we already have 'diameter_crown'. It can be defined that it refers to the average size when used on areas with several trees.

177177976

Hi,
can anybody shop here 24/7 or do you need some kind of membership card?
node/9021268964

177323942

A key can't end with a colon - it should be either 'ref' or 'ref:XYZ'.

177190092

Hier fehlt die Art der authentication:
way/222850704
disc?

177232243

Hi,
this is the only occurrence of "payment:inpost" - but we have many "payment:inpost_mobile". Is this the same?

177159550

Perfect :)
styrofoam is actually listed in the table as "polystyrene_foam".
The wiki table is for sure not complete, but it's always a good starting point.

Another place to search is the list of tags that are actually in use, Taginfo:
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/recycling#similar
As you can see there are about 200 recycling:* tags that are used more than say 10 times each.

If there's something that can't be found in any existing tag, you're always free to invent your own new one.

One more thing:
There's the tag
operator wikidata=Q135270647
The "wikidata" should be part of the key:
operator:wikidata Q135270647

Happy Mapping!

177323942

Hi,
something doesn't seem to be right here. There are 12 objects with a strange "ref:" key. Could you check that?

177159550

Hi & welcome to OSM!

You're using many recycling-related tags here that are not common.
Please have a look to the documented tags in the wiki and use only these - only well-defined tags can be understood by other mappers and can be shown on maps and in applications.

Here's the relevant table with common tags:
amenity=recycling#Recycling