OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
177000613

Hi, and welcome to OSM!
You have to make sure that you only use data from sources that are licensed to be used for OSM. google does not allow to use its data for OSM, so I had to revert these edits.

176996294

Hi,
you used many 'addr:...' keys here that are not used in any other place. Please use only those tags that are described in the wiki or are present as presets in the editor - everything else can not be found by any search function.

176667051

Where did you find an approval of 'source:url'? It's just a specific form of 'source', i.e. the source of the 'url' tag - although it has been misused by several large imports. It isn't even explicitly mentioned in the wiki.

'source_ref' is the tag for external source links that is used millions of times since the beginning of OSM.

176831831

Hi, please check the presets / auto-completion in your editor. It shouldn't be 'eaf_cycle', but 'leaf_cycle'.
I fixed a few dozens of them.

176868343

Hi,
these power poles got some uncommon tags:

BSK= Derby 33kV
GSP= Willington
Primary Substaion= Mackworth 33 11kV

Please check the wiki how those reference codes are typically tagged.

176874972

Hi,
what does 'through_traffic=no' mean? That's usually excluded by using vehicle=destination.

Also, are even pedestrians not allowed to walk here? Otherwise 'access=destination' is wrong and should be 'vehicle=destination'.

176833448

Hi,
what does 'recycling:bundles' mean? This tag is not used in any other place.

176801528

Hier ist noch einer übrig geblieben:
node/1976962915

176794147

Right, destination:distance is better in this context. Essentially using the options we have for destination signs also for milestones.

In the case of a milestone with arrows we could also use
direction_north and direction_north:distance

distance:City seems to be a quite local phenomenon:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/2if8

176801688

Hi,
hier fehlen die Tags an der Relation:
relation/20044848

176794147

Hi Robert,
wouldn't it be better to replace those "old school" "distance:Nelson Monument" tags with a more modern tagging that doesn't use free text in the key? This would do the job - and at the same time also keep the order of entries on the milestone:

destination = A City; B Village; C Place
distance = 10 mi;2 mi;234 mi

Using 'destination' on a milestone seems appropriate to me, even though it's not a guidepost pointing in the right direction...

176801528

In einem Value ist das auch weniger ein Problem, aber für Keys nicht geeignet.

Meiner persönlichen Meinung nach gehört das ohnehin gar nicht in den Key. Lieber in einer sauberen, nummerierten, maschinenlesbaren Form inklusive eindeutigem Link zu wikidata:

railway:name:1
railway:ref:1
railway:operator:1
railway:operator:1:wikidata

Wenn aber ein Name im Key erwünscht ist, dann so kurz wie (eindeutig) möglich, aber mit Leerzeichen durch Unterstriche ersetzt und ohne Semikolons.

Und als letztes Argument möchte ich erwähnen, dass diese Tags am Knoten eigentlich gar nicht nötig sind: Ich brauche nur auf die beiden anschließenden ways zu sehen um diese Information zu bekommen.

176799946

Hi,
could you check this node, it got no proper tags:
node/13429412538

176782878

Hi,
'gbt' is not a socket type, but a standard defining many sockets. Please check the precise type - I guess it is "gb_dc".

176801528

Hallo,
du hast hier neue "railway:name:xxxxxxxx" mit sehr langen Namen inklusive Leerzeichen und Sonderzeichen verwendet. Diese sollten in Keys generell nicht auftauchen. Könntest du das bitte ändern?

Andere "railway:name:XXX" keys verwenden kurze Akronyme, siehe hier: https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/railway%3Aname#similar

176755713

If that's not the source, the tag should not be added. On the original building the source was correctly given in the changeset. When you set it to 'demolished', you added the tag, which you claim was not the source - which means it's wrong and shouldn't be there.

47111226

Thanks for the information!
How about this full set of descriptive tags?

tourism=information
information=route_marker
material=brass
height = 0
support = ground
ref = XXX
operator = Thornbury & District Museum
name = Thornbury Heritage Trail
url = https://www.thornburymuseum.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/Heritage_Trail_Guide_for_website.pdf

47111226

Hi,
I found 15 nodes with the key "southglos:heritagetrail"
node/4751832643

What do they represent? A board with information? trail blazes?

176728838

Hi,
when you're checking these bus stops, could you also update the tagging? 'lines' is deprecated since several years and should be replaced by 'route_ref'.

16045593

Hi,
hast du noch eine Ahnung was diese Tags an den Masten hier bedeuten? In 12 Jahren hat das wohl niemand nach dir noch getagged...

node/2296882665
2dcode
Dreieck
Kreis
Quadrat