OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
176335483

Please don't add 47 (!) images to a single object. OSM is not a gallery.
If there are many images, you can link e.g. to a wikimedia_commons category.

176349508

Hi,
could you check these edits? All these proposed barriers crossing major roads seem a bit suspicious.

Btw, 'proposed' is a prefix, the proper tag would be 'proposed:barrier'.

176040612

I agree that a revert is the proper way to proceed.

176268505

Hi,
you added several tags here that shouldn't be in OSM, e.g.
"source:maxspeed:named_numbered" or
"source:maxspeed:app"

Could you check and fix this?

176067309

Hi,
could you check these edits? "psv=no" contradicts "oneway:bus=no".

176164427

Hi,
please don't add dozens of plain translations to name and address tags. The address of an object should be just the official address in the official language of the place (sometimes there are 2 or 3, but never more than 20).
The same goes for the name which should contain only official names in other languages, but no plain translations.

176040612

cc-by-4.0 is not suitable for OSM.
https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/03/17/use-of-cc-by-data/

You need to obtain a special permission using e.g. this letter:
https://osmfoundation.org/wiki/Licence/Waiver_and_Permission_Templates/Cover_letter_and_waiver_template_for_CC_BY_4.0

176171955

Hi,
I agree that especially for short operator names there might be the risk of conflicts. However, the scheme without 'operator' is by far the most common scheme.
However, if there is some discussion you have my full support for "officially" recommending adding 'operator' to the name tag.

176011534

Stimmt hier "parking:right:psv:conditional" wirklich? 'psv' schließt Taxis mit ein, die damit rund um die Uhr dort parken dürfen.

way/1102612746

175997160

Hi,
what does "wine_tourism" mean? This tag isn't used in any other place.

176040612

Hi,
please don't dump data from external sources into OSM.
All these waterways have a large number of foreign tags that should not be in OSM.

Please read our import guidelines:
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

175907560

My concern is the missing "s" :-)

175999828

Tags wie diese an einem einzelnen Objekt sind normalerweise ein klares Zeichen, dass fremde Daten importiert wurden und vergessen wurde tags richtig anzupassen.
Neue Keys sollten der allgemeinen Form entsprechen, z.B. kein CamelCase
osm.wiki/Any_tags_you_like#How_to_name_new_tags

Was spricht gegen schon etablierte Tags, z.B. das in Polen übliche osm.wiki/Pl:Key:highway:category:pl

Da es sich hier sicherlich um eine lokale Einordnung handelt, sollte das am Tag auch klar erkennbar sein.

Da die Klassifizierung von Straßen ein sehr weitreichendes Problem ist (das auch schon häufig diskutiert wurde), sollte es zunächst im Forum besprochen werden.

175907560

Hi,
could you check your edits? There are at least 9 'macot' and 'macot:...' tags around the world.

175903447

Hi,
thanks for the explanation!
Please don't add such data to the global OSM database if they are just for you research - other users of the data can't make any use of it.

There are much better places for that, e.g. displayed via umap.

175635916

You can remove the space, but it is not required. I'm sure that every tool that handles the ';' properly also can work with white space before and after.
E.g. osm.org properly adds links no matter if there is a space or not.

175928895

I read the tag as the alternative name of the related law, which doesn't make sense.
Wouldn't the law related to the name not be better tagged as
alt_name:related_law , similar to e.g. alt_name:wikipedia ?

175903447

Hi,
what do these tags mean? They are not used in any other place:

capacity:diario
capacity:lunes

175898636

Hallo,
ein paar Fragen...

können hier tatsächlich 6x6=36 Lastwagen gleichzeitig laden?

"CCS" ist kein Steckertyp, ich nehme mal an, du meinst "type2_combo"?

Wieviele von dieser Sorte gibt es?

Bitte verwende nicht "amenity_2". Immer einen eigenen Node verwenden, sonst werden diese Informationen nicht nutzbar sein. Wahrscheinlich hat ohnehin nicht jeder Ladepunkt eine eigene Dusche und Verkaufsautomat?

175828350

Are you sure there is gate right in the middle of this major road?