Hi there, is `disused:highway=*` an editing mistake?

This changeset lgtm. Firstly `=no` is clearly wrong as e.g. construction workers can obviously still use it. From what I gathered online, pedestrians are still allowed, so `motor_vehicle=private` looks good. But might need to check bicycle restrictions. That's not mutually exclusive with `was:highway=tertiary`.

Reverted due to incompatible source

changeset/184695500

Why?

changeset/184692859

Reverted due to incompatible source

changeset/184692074

Reverted due to incompatible source

changeset/184684579

1. Why did you change `building=` to `building:parts=`? way/428763450
2. Do you have a source for "Stone House Family Park"?
3. Please do not delete and then redraw any objects. This makes tracking history difficult, and wastes previous mappers' effort. Simply edit the geometry or tags.
4. Why did you remove the address and `building=` from way/687742644 ?

Descriptive name?

1. Have you considered the possibility that there is just no name?

2. It's definitely not gone because I saw it with my own eyes a few days ago.

MOS Road <-> Tai Po Road (and hence Shing Mun and Tsing Sha) deserves `=tertiary` at least imo. This is the only way without any traffic lights, at least until T4 opens, so it should be somewhat competitive.

Why? Shouldn't the higher one be used?

At least, it's what Kovoschiz told me: changeset/180237869

Is it really appropriate to use `landuse=cemetery` for columbaria?

Informal alternative routes exist. There's many discussion about it on the OSM World Discord. Iirc the conclusion is that it just can't be handled with normal PT relations. But imo this doesn't mean we can't map the stops. Recall previous discussion about bus stop names: "Just because the government doesn't explicitly say it exist, doesn't mean it doesn't exist!"

Well first grass has nothing to do with this. And then, pictures of heaths on the wiki look nothing like any typical Hong Kong roadside plantations.

Creating non-existent physical separation is wrong though. It's not just not good enough. "Simple stuff" doesn't mean you can be as lazy as you want to.

Please note that Youtube cannot be used as a source for OSM

changeset/184417534

Your link points to a community centre of some sort that is equipped with a drinking water, not a drinking water named "地海深居（土木工程處社區聯絡中心）"

Is it really a drinking water?

Hi there, to denote urban vs NT taxi stands, simply use `taxi=private` + `taxi:HK:Urban=yes` or `taxi:HK:NT=yes`. Hope this helps!