Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530980 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164531140 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

Hi Ben Stillss, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164531140 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

Hi ccoliva, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530482 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

Hi ccoliva, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530482 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

Hi ccoliva, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530482 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

Hi ccoliva, these changes appear to be vandalism. Reverted in changeset/164530482 and reported to the OSM Data Working Group.

I've reverted this with changeset/164383169

Hi DDOLL, can you explain the tag deletions in this changeset?

Hi, spotted this odd sidewalk bridge segment: way/1309494303

Is this a mistake?

Feel free to join us in OSM-US's #local-nyc slack channel (https://osmus.slack.com/archives/C4DPLAN3U) as we hash this out together over the next few years ;)

Thanks for the typo fix ;)

I removed the fixme tag -- it's hard to have a conversation that way! But to answer your question -- these are the "official" toll zone boundaries & yes without a doubt they are wonky. But it's not the the piers were added, rather that first everything on Manhattan Island south of 61st was included, and then certain sections of highway were removed, leaving all these separate outer ways.

We will of course continue to improve this relation over time, based on survey of the toll scanners themselves. I suspect that way/1348722214 can be made much smaller, and maybe some like way/1348722217 way/1348722218 and way/1348722219 can be removed altogether.