Changeset When Comment
186666462

Hi thanks for this, is that how the name is signed on site?

Their website has "St Mary & St Paul’s CE Primary School", and it was "..CofE..."

185948290

Hi, this area looks well mapped, thank you. However, in your improvements you seem to have removed the name from the school itself, so I've put that back

186900280

Hi, I'm not sure if the options aren't clear enough, but for individual terraced houses, "Terraced houses" is not the appropriate option (that's for a whole row as one building), "House" is the best option in this case, which is how this group were mapped:
way/1496350625

186595761

Hi, I'm not sure if the options aren't clear enough, but for individual terraced houses, "Terraced houses" is not the appropriate option (that's for a whole row as one building), "House" is the best option in this case

186874358

Hi, thanks for adding these, it would be good to fix the building tag at the same time. building=terrace being for the unsplit outline and building=house, house=terraced for individual houses after splitting

I've fixed them here

186996337

Fair enough, and their website only mentioned start times, not end times

And I guess fair for the comments too

186996337

Sorry, also this node/3173126650
There is the happy_hours=* tag

And node/3936724894 any reason for removing the comments?

Don't mean to be picky or negative, but just doing some additional QA

186996337

Re: node/7697618458
Ranges are permissible in service_times, so there's a slight loss of information here by removing that (obviously the format was incorrect and invalid and this is an improvement in that aspect)

180615663

I guess I wasn't a hundred percent sure. I also see that @Dezza has since noted that there is no phone number advertised on site: note/5226062

Although it is possibly only 01524 3.. and 01524 6... that can have 5 digit local numbers

185508804

I see that you added this swimming pool as both a swimming pool and as a disused pool, which is it?
way/1537339250
Thanks

186644157

This autocorrection should not be suggested from the next run, after updating to the latest opening_hours version. I don't know of an easy way to search for people who applied the incorrect edit. I keep half an eye on an OSMCha feed of changesets from the tool and don't recall seeing others doing edits in Poland recently

186644157

Thank you, in general I avoided So>Su for that reason, and I believe this was the only such change that I made. Based on the context of Mo-Sa being defined here and "So" having some different value, I felt that it was almost certain that it should be Sunday.

182895515

It doesn't change the fact that the name is not in French and there is currently no way to tell that programmatically, or to determine which language it is in.

Anyway, I have joined the forum discussion

182895515

> In France name == name:fr

Clearly that is mostly correct, but not universally true, e.g. node/5003135252

Therefore such cases as this are interesting and much more difficult to find given the current state of the data.

> The consensus in France is to NOT duplicate name into name:fr.

Is there a particular place where this was discussed, I'm not sure what best to search for? It does go against the statement on the (English) wiki, and makes it impossible for data consumers to be certain of the language of an element.

186353618

I was meaning things like way/363404167 where you changed it from an unspecified building to a terrace. The problem is that you selected "Terraced houses", which should only be used for when there's a long row of houses all mapped as one building. Here, where the houses are mapped separately, you should choose the "House" option. I think it could be clearer, personally

176291657

I seem to remember that the outline here was broken, possibly unclosed or something, so that was my fix. I don't think I was aligning it to a known outline. I did visit the Botanical Gardens but I don't remember the exact outline for the Healing Garden.

Without further information, I am assuming that the map you provided is copyrighted and not suitable for use with OSM so I don't think I can make any edits here, apologies

186009622

Thanks for this, I just made a couple of adjustments, first the building type should be "terraced house", not "row of terraced houses".

Secondly we for houses like this we should only have addr:housename, we don't need the same value again in the name

186134830

Thanks, and I've just spotted my typo, it should be house=terraced

186029601

Hi, thanks for these, they seem to line up well and be good shapes. Just a note on the tagging. I think building=terrace should be kept for an (unsplit) terrace row and for individual houses, as you've done here, it should be building=house, house=terraced, which I've fixed these to

186353618

Hi, I'm not sure if the options aren't clear enough, but for individual terraced houses, "Terraced houses" is not the appropriate option, "House" is the best option in this case