OpenStreetMap
citrula's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 147381565 | I went ahead and fixed it, and also removed the name. For future reference, you can right click the node and select "extract" to take the node off of a way. Also, we don't use descriptive names - access=private and the gate is already sufficient to prevent routers from sending people on the road. |
|
| 147381565 | Welcome to OSM! The address node should not be on the road, but rather roughly in the center of the building with that address. Happy mapping!
|
|
| 147384856 | Welcome to OSM. A few things I noticed - Street names should be unabbreviated ("Parwelk St" should be "Parwelk Street" instead). Also, service=parking_aisle should be reserved for service roads which are only used to access parking spots - the main service road that you use to get in/out of a lot should not be a parking aisle. Let me know if you have any other questions, and happy mapping!
|
|
| 147226748 | Welcome back to OSM. You can press "q" in iD to square the corners of buildings you draw! Happy mapping!
|
|
| 147194935 | I fixed the highway geometry in this changeset:
It looks like you drew the same road multiple times. I deleted those as well. |
|
| 147106291 | amenity=fountain is for decorative fountains. You can always refer to the wiki to see how the tag is expected to be used. For example, the page for drinking water: amenity=drinking_water You can refer to the "Useful combinations" section, or just look at the fields that iD presents you with. |
|
| 147187422 | Welcome to OSM. Thanks for your contributions!
|
|
| 147156673 | Welcome to OSM! A few things - please don't use generic names like "house" - the name key should only be used for the name that the object is referred to as. Also, please press "Q" to square the corners of objects you draw using iD. Happy mapping!
|
|
| 147106291 | Is this a drinking fountain/water fountain? If so, you can tag it with amenity=drinking_water instead
|
|
| 147106167 | looks good to me! welcome to OSM!
|
|
| 147059721 | You dragged some nodes around from Hillard road. I fixed it, but please be careful! |
|
| 147029152 | Please don't use descriptive names. I fixed the tagging of the retaining pond, but maybe you could help identify whether it is for detention or retention? If it is is for detention, you probably will be able to identify a clear inflow and outflow.
|
|
| 147029152 | Please don't use descriptive names. I fixed the tagging of the retaining pond, but maybe you could help identify whether it is for detention or retention? If it is is for detention, you probably will be able to identify a clear inflow and outflow.
|
|
| 146982053 | That isn't meant to be a gotcha or anything, I really hope that this sort of work "surfacing" older/outdated data will help with getting POIs updated. There's a bot on mastodon which does something similar: https://botsin.space/@restobot |
|
| 146982053 | Thanks for your response. I'm familiar with the check_date tag, I just haven't seen it being used in such a way (adding an older date). Are you using this for BTCMap in some way? I'm curious how you determine whether the user actually surveyed its existence or not? For example, on this POI node/7056211216 , check_date was set to 2023-03-17, and the changeset from that date was someone doing tag cleanup with Osmose - almost certainly not a survey. |
|
| 147024976 | The highway=crossing nodes are not indicating the existence of a traffic signal. They show where there is a signalized pedestrian crossing. I added them back
|
|
| 146989054 | Press "Q" to square corners of objects in iD! :)
|
|
| 146913145 | I have removed this railway as it is not present at all. |
|
| 146982053 | Can you explain what "bump check date" means? Where is the information for when it is last checked coming from?
|
|
| 146986510 | Welcome to OSM, thanks for your contributions!
|