citrula's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 153815563 | I'm not sure that there is actually physical separation on the driveways - they should only be a single way
|
|
| 153815781 | I reverted your edits. Please don't remove random tags and make only one object for each feature. |
|
| 152198871 | Thanks for the fix. Next time I hike through, I will confirm the north one - I only walked across the southern crossing last time I was there. |
|
| 153733518 | Also, please don't delete and recreate objects - it's better to modify existing ones to preserve the history.
|
|
| 153733518 | Welcome to OSM! Please don't add future/planned objects - wait until they are present in real life :)
|
|
| 152198871 | I don't think there's any bridges in Westside preserve. Did you mean to add them (instead of fords?) |
|
| 153729365 | Did you mean to remove the residential area for "The Preserve" neighborhood?
|
|
| 153761532 | Welcome to OSM - Google Maps is not an acceptable source for edits. See: osm.wiki/Google
|
|
| 153723082 | Thanks for the fix!
|
|
| 153682976 | reverted |
|
| 153682976 | You dragged some motorway nodes around and marked a random service road as a highway=trunk toll=yes
|
|
| 153567634 | Tags on OSM are free-form. proposed:* tag prefix wiki page says the following: " Proposed features that are not visible on the ground should therefore only be mapped in exceptional cases and after a discussion with the relevant OSM community, lest they might be deleted for lack of verifiability." In general, proposed features are only mapped when it is certain that it will be there in the future, and the path is well-defined. Whether or not the trail was mapped by an organization has little bearing on this. |
|
| 153567634 | That one should not be there either - I just saw this one as it was coming through my changeset QA feeds. Reviewing changesets is a volunteer effort, so not every change is able to be scrutinized - if you disagree with the response given here I encourage you to post on the community forums for more visibility |
|
| 153569850 | Can you explain what the "Major Edit" you made here is, exactly? |
|
| 153567634 | It's best to just wait until the trail is completed to add it to the map. Proposed and future features don't belong on OSM. |
|
| 153567634 | Does "Future American Perimeter Trail" exist right now?
|
|
| 153556273 | Reverted |
|
| 148622158 | The unpaved portion of Thompson Street is highway=track at most, and most likely not signed as a street - maybe an abandoned roadbed based on 3DEP |
|
| 153453068 | I have reverted your changes because you are vandalising the map. Please be more careful with your edits in the future. |
|
| 153210974 | Is the parking lot gone? If so, please remove the entire object as well. If you are trying to do something else I'd be happy to help, but removing only the amenity tag doesn't really make much sense
|