Hi @bradrh. Looks like you had a fun Thanksgiving weekend on your bike.

When uploading GPS tracks, you might want to zoom in and edit out any spots where you stopped to admire the view or catch your breath. The GPS will jitter and leave a cluster of poorly aligned points.

It's actually easier than I thought it would be. Try this:
1) draw an area around a forest
2) draw an area around some residential property inside that forest
3) hold down shift and select the outer area. you should now have two areas selected.
4) press "C" to combine the two.
5) click on the border shading inside of the forest area and set it to "Wood"
6) click on the border shading inside of the residential area and set it to "Residential".

Let me know if that doesn't work. And thanks for working with me on this. It will save me a lot of work in the future.

I'm pretty sure that the correct, manual of style way is to use an inner polygon for the non wood types of the outer polygon. If that is too difficult with the given tools, I'd venture to guess that making the whole area a forest and then adding some buildings inside the forest would be acceptable and wouldn't trigger any errors.
Do you need help learning how to create multipolygons, or is there another issue that makes them onerous?

Hi again Bkissin,

I'd love it if you could stop doing the following style of mapping: https://imgur.com/a/oaR0j1m since it gets tagged by validators like OSM Inspector and I end up going in and cleaning it up. If you can't use multipolygons, at least don't use the same nodes going out of the "island" as you do going in. It's them crossing or overlapping that sets off error flags.
Thanks.

I already added it manually, so there is nothing that you need to do now. What @freebeer is trying to do is replace my brand new building by restoring the old one so that there is some history. If he succeeds, great. If not, it isn't the end of the world.

Fantastic. Thanks for getting back to me. And sorry for the temporary problems.

Thanks! I'm guessing the "construction" tags could also be removed at this point?

Does the pipeline (way/493374720) really double back on itself like that? I split it into two so that it wouldn't be invalid (ways can't cross over themselves without a junction).

Hi @Bkissin. I fixed up your wooded area around the Shallow Pond in changeset/64884669

It was generating errors because of the segments that went in to surround the lake and then came back out over the same segment. You don't have to draw around the pond a second time, you just mark it as an "inner" polygon. I'm not sure how easy this is to do in iD. It's pretty simple in JOSM if you ever decide to switch.

Wrong changeset comment. Should be "Fixing up ways that intersect with themselves/others"

Removed in changeset/64872509

Hi John-Michael. Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Are you really a brand new user, or is this just a brand new account?
The changes you made are quite drastic, especially for someone new to OSM. A lot of people see that streets aren't aligned to imagery so they move things to match the imagery. The only problem is that other imagery might not agree with where you moved things and someone else might move them back. How did you verify that your alignment is actually correct?
Thanks.

Hi @neil561. I'm trying to understand why the building with the way/251903141 was converted into a multipolygon. Is there some reason for it, or is it just a mistake made while editing?

OK. I thought that might be the case. I was confused when I saw it, but figured that had to be a good reason.

I wonder why way/540952850 isn't part of the larger, neighboring park. Seems kind of odd to have that one split off.

Did you come home from Black Friday sales looking for some OSM task to use your new laptop for??

Yeah, I'd love it if you could replace the original building outline. Thanks for the assist!

Nope. We're all good. I've been doing this for a year now and I probably learn something new every day. Just keep on mapping and don't worry about breaking anything. We can always fix up innocent mistakes later.

Well, I tried to restore it along with history, but my editor and restoration tool has a bug so I couldn't do it the easy way. I've gone ahead and drawn it out by hand instead.

Yes. I'll make sure of it. (I'm surprised to hear about Shiva being gone. I used to eat there when I lived in MV.)

No worries. Glad to have more people improving the data. Adding the building back is better because it will save the history of the element. But it is a little tricky. I'll go ahead and restore it for you.
If you ever have any questions, feel free to reach out.