archie's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 84772679 | Well this is getting a touch of unseriousness. May last words on this: The newer name-form is Svarttjärnen. On older maps it is Svarttjärn and probably in local folks memory as well. You could of course make yourself a laughing stock considering "Svarttjärn" the "correct" name. https://kso.etjanster.lantmateriet.se/?e=324907&n=6400050&z=12 https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svarttj%C3%A4rnen_(G%C3%B6teborg%2C_V%C3%A4sterg%C3%B6tland) https://www.lansstyrelsen.se/download/18.2e0f9f621636c84402719336/1527745491763/G%C3%B6teborg.pdf Mind you; there is an other lake in Göteborg, tagged in 2008 as "Svarttjärn" but on lantmäteriets maps named "Svarttjärnen". way/23195032. There has obviously been a shift in naming-procedure. But some friends of mine, living in this area, are insisting that the truely, correct name is "Svarttjärnet". Should we consider "Svarttjärnet" the "correct" name now? |
|
| 84782993 | It dosn't work this way. I advise you to read about the principales of osm here osm.wiki/Sv:Beginners%27_guide |
|
| 84850993 | You changed the geometry of yours from yesterday. But have a closer look at the stream way/74010827. Continues through a building and deviates in the woodland area from lantmäteriet quite a bit, don't you think so? |
|
| 84850692 | Why is this tree linked to path way/801386707?
|
|
| 84790682 | Are you now in for a tit for tat? See even comments for cs #84772679. |
|
| 84772679 | Re DWG: please see osm.wiki/Data_working_group Re sloppy: Yes of course you are quite right. When you changed the names of the lakes in cs #84772531 and later in cs #84772679 after I had raised objections about this in cs #84767999 this was not sloppieness but faul intent. In this one (1) day you have been active as a user you have ventured around the world quite a bit https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-suspicious?uid=11135477#2/-17.1/112.3 So the edits you did in this cs (changeset/84778570), I would call sloppy (way/800818756) and (way/800818754). When you venture that far after just having started editing, you should have acquired sufficient basic knowledge not to make this kind of error (place=islet). |
|
| 84772679 | I did switch to English, because I suspect that your rather sloppy cs would be of intrest for the DWG.
|
|
| 84772679 | You could use old_name=* |
|
| 84772531 | I have reverted your changesets #84772531 and #84772679. cs #84772531 has been commented before in cs #84767999. In the reverted cs you deviate from what the swedish agency for geodata - Lantmäteriverket - states regarding the names of lakes.
You have - without having given any credible source - changed to Svarttjärn, Prästtjärn, Furåstjärn, Blacktjärn, Björnåstjärn, Bergåstjärn and Hindtjärn. You have stated that it dosn't "feel good" with Svarttjärnen etc. [in comment to cs #84767999] You may have noticed, that even the other lakes around has names with endings -en or -et. Please do keep these names in accordance with the official names. If you are certain that there are other local names for these lakes use alt_name=* or loc_name= respectively. |
|
| 84772679 | I have reverted your changesets #84772531 and #84772679. cs #84772531 has been commented before in cs #84767999. In the reverted cs you deviate from what the swedish agency for geodata - Lantmäteriverket - states regarding the names of lakes.
You have - without having given any credible source - changed to Svarttjärn, Prästtjärn, Furåstjärn, Blacktjärn, Björnåstjärn, Bergåstjärn and Hindtjärn. You have stated that it dosn't "feel good" with Svarttjärnen etc. [in comment to cs #84767999] You may have noticed, that even the other lakes around has names with endings -en or -et. Please do keep these names in accordance with the official names. If you are certain that there are other local names for these lakes use alt_name=* or loc_name= respectively. |
|
| 84755539 | jag såg att du rättade. bra |
|
| 84767999 | Du skulle ju kunna tillfoga alt_name=Svarttjärn |
|
| 84770086 | Även denna sjö har bestämd form på lantmäteriets kartor. way/10305111 |
|
| 84755539 | Är du helt säker på att det är en kulvert här? På satellitfotot ser det väldigt likt ut som en bro. |
|
| 84756293 | När man använder denna väg way/800707170; kan man komma till Sättingsvägen? |
|
| 84767999 | Enligt lantmäteriets kartor har denna sjö namnet "Svarttjärnen"; dvs bestämd form. Varför tycker du att det skall göras avsteg från lantmäteriets uppgifter härvidlag? |
|
| 83415150 | Ok, thanks for clarification. Thanks also for the mail :-) |
|
| 83415150 | Thank you. Most intressting. This leads to two questions: 1.) why isn't this pointed out more clearly in osm.wiki/Addresses "Buildings with multiple house numbers"? 2.) why is there a separat delimiter for address? Are there any other instances where semicolon is not the valid delimiter? |
|
| 84613060 | Snyggt! Är det spelplanen som heter Vinåvallen eller hela idrottsanläggningen? |
|
| 84555760 | This (way/799313511/history) isn't really a path all the way is it? |