looks good. There is a clear "Private Road" sign showing for Sea Street so all good. https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-33.83224722222223&lng=151.150425&z=17&focus=photo&pKey=kX6AM3TbnIBbucyHzmHizA&x=0.4532493606392&y=0.5196650251542435&zoom=0.8103975535168195

If signposted it's still okay to map the relation, because you're mapping the signage.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/91797243

The tag for driveways is highway=service + service=driveway, I've fixed this.

also highway=service + service=driveway is the tag to use for these driveways I've fixed that up in changeset/91570614 see service=driveway

I've unglued the power line which you glued to the road changeset/91570584

Usually there are no pedestrian signs where you can't walk, so assuming those are present here, then all good.

hi I updated the name and ref for way/45728168 based on sinage

hi what's your source for the speed limit and name? this road was already mapped with a different name. Since this added a duplicate road segment on top I'll revert in the meantime.

hi what's your source for the speed limit and classification? This road was already mapped, the one you added was a duplicate on top so I'll revert this for now until you can confirm.

hi, generally if you're adding many buildings if you could do a few before uploading instead of saving each building as a changeset.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/91396007

Hi welcome to OpenStreetMap. It looks like you've traced out a few driveways as areas and tagged them as buildings. Things should only be tagged building where they are a structure with walls and a roof, which is not a driveway, you can map driveways as a linear way (line) and tag it as a driveway instead.
Also for buildings it should be the footprint of the building not the whole land parcel, so the backyard shouldn't be included.

Great work. I saw this one recently but wasn't on my bike so didn't manage to grab a trace. There looked like cycleway on the eastern side too.

Probably the hosted routing engines didn't update. When I tested now with the GraphHopper hosted router on osm.org it avoids routing through Walumetta Drive, but will route through it if the end point is along it (which is how it should work for destination).
OSRM hosted by FOSSGIS might not have updated, or it might not handle destination correctly.

Generally creating no-existent paths for the router is controversial. I've been tollerant of the ones going along beaches, even though I don't agree with them (there's no marked path along the beach so it shouldn't be mapped as a bath), but this is just an open area from the imagery I can't see much evidence of a path, is there anything on the ground?

Though true these should have been with the :lanes suffix like you added, but the destination part comes from you being allowed to drive in a bus lane if you're accessing a driveway (ie. destination along the road). Not saying this is how it should work, but it's explains why.

the tags you removed here were lane tags, so the access restrictions only applied to the left lane not the whole road. This is tagging per osm.wiki/Australian_Tagging_Guidelines#Bus_Lanes_and_Bus_Only_Lanes happy to discuss if this is correct or not but probably needs a wider discussion on the list.

Oops, good catch.

Okay thanks for the explanation. However in that case motor_vehicle=no is not correct because it blocks even residents from access. For no through routes the documented way to may this is with the destination access value, see access=*#List_of_possible_values ie. motor_vehicle=destination. I've updated the tag based on this.

I've also added the turn restrictions as I could see from Mapillary and as you've indicated here at the Gas Works Road end.

PS. it's fine to use @username for the twitter details, contact:twitter=* specified that either the page URL or @username is fine.

Do you need a relation here? You can add a way which covers the grounds and then add any buildings inside the grounds, and then the spatial relationship shows which buildings are part of the fire station. eg way/42441888