There also appears to be an unattached place node for Jenks:
node/151731482

admin_centre is only used for administrative centers such as capitals and county seats. Label is used for holding the ordinary place node associated with a boundary. Typically entities below county wouldn't have an admin_centre role.

Harassment sock puppet account Shipu Innu documented at osm.wiki/User:ZeLonewolf/Sockpuppets

I could use a hand untangling this MEX 1 / BCS 1 routes as they're mixed up in the changeset where I updated the federal highway 1 route.

I've restored the way tagging and added a route relation:
relation/13915662

Can you determine whether the northernmost section is supposed to be there? It was tagged that way originally.

Hey thanks for the note. I was working on mapping the Mexico federal highways (e.g. highway 2: relation/70954). I found these cases of ref=MEX 2 which looked like they were in error. So I guess I'm confused - do the federal highways and state highways use the same ref scheme? How can you tell the difference between them? I am sure your data source is correct but now I'm not sure how the tagging is supposed to differentiate these two classes of highway.

For anyone confused by this discussion, it's a continuation of the discussion on changeset/118237480

Fixed in changeset/117867523

I think this particular edit is okay and should stand. It's accepted practice that motorway islands should not be tagged for a single grade separated intersection.

Discussion thread on talk-ca:
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca/2022-February/010343.html

Thanks @Spaghetti Monster for reverting this change. I agree that given the quality issues that a rollback was necessary.

@CarniLvr79, openstreetmap is a community project, and it's important for you to listen to the concerns of other mappers and not dismiss them.

Specifically, polygons are are allowed to overlap when features overlap. If a feature is on top of another feature, then those polygons representing them should overlap as well, with the layer=* tag used to indicate which ones are on top.

For buildings, the convention is to map the actual footprint of the building, not just the bits you're able to see during summer imagery when leaves are on the trees.

Go away Michael.

Thanks for taking on this cleanup!

I disagree that a change in physical construction style should change a highway's classification value. Highway classifications for trunk and below are based on the road's connectivity value in the road network. A road should not toggle back and forth between classification values, it should have one consistent value through its entire length.

This road might be primary, consistent with the surrounding road network, or it might be trunk, part of a much longer trunk routing through the UP. However, it cannot be trunk while the surrounding roads are primary.

This is described in more detail in osm.wiki/United_States/2021_Highway_Classification_Guidance

I'd encourage you to join the OSM US Slack, slack.openstreetmap.us, where these topics are discussed in great detail in the channel #local-michigan and #highway-classification.

That's not really an acceptable response. If you are going to replace a feature, you need to do it in one changeset. Now that you've deleted that patch of woods, it's missing from the map with only the promise of adding it back in the future.

Hi, can you explain why you deleted this patch of wood?

way/526651029

This was a validly mapped wooded area.

Thanks!

Corrected description: Mexico Federal routes 2 and 2D

Thanks for the feedback. The importance-based classification system that has emerged as a national consensus is supported by dozens of mappers that have collaborated on writing this documentation. I'm sorry that you find this insufficient, but I'm not seeing any willingness on your part to constructively participate. Since you've stated several times that you don't care either way, I'm going to go ahead and implement the consensus classification. Thanks for the discussion.

Expressways should be tagged expressway=yes. Trunk roads should be classified consistently with osm.wiki/United_States/2021_Highway_Classification_Guidance