OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
179849379

Hi,
relation/20321527 ... first a one member multipolygon relation is data bloat - just put the tag/s on the way and delete the relation.
However in this case it is an error - the outer has not been added... so I have done that and transferred the tags from the outer way to the relation.

179841490

And where does the Sydney to Melbourne XPT route 19744551 now run???
Was on Way: North Eastern Standard Gauge Line (135649140), Way: ARTC Standard Gauge Line (961587018) and Way: ARTC Standard Gauge Line (1484485186)

171381614

Further
the multipoluygon should not share segments on the outer ways.

In this case I have deleted the relation . Combined the 2 ways into one way and placed the tags on that way.

171381614

Hi
A multipolygon members should have 'roles' .. in this case 'outers'/
The tags on the multipolygon should no repeat the tags on the ways.

166797454

Relation deleted - shared segments, no roles
Made simple way that includes surrounds and tagged that as community centre (no building tag as those are on the actual buildings)

179373891

Changeset comment should be
Resolve 'Moore Guy' from relation into simple way.
Source - OSMInspector, OSM, bing

91734873

Hi,
Why have you marked Charters Towers Aerodrome as military?
It was constructed for military purposes .. but now?
Looks like it is controlled by hte local council - they collect landing fees & charges...
https://www.charterstowers.qld.gov.au/Services/Facilities-and-services/Airports-airstrips

59353503

Hi,
Issue with Relation: Bingera Conservation Park 1 (1506713)...

This looks to be a gliders airfield - North Gregory/Elliott Field https://www.pilotnav.com/airport/YETT

Primarily used by https://gliding.inbundy.com.au/gliding/

Maybe it is 'used ' for both ???

----------- I have also raised this on changeset/106895639

106895639

Hi,
Issue with Relation: Bingera Conservation Park 1 (1506713)...

This looks to be a gliders airfield - North Gregory/Elliott Field https://www.pilotnav.com/airport/YETT

Primarily used by https://gliding.inbundy.com.au/gliding/

Maybe it is 'used ' for both ???

179330035

Changeset comment should be
Add Caboolture Gliding Club. Add some buildings, fences. Expand parking from node to area.

179250624

The relation for the Smallwood Estate is not how it was originally mapped. I like this one better. But as a 1 member relation it can be simplified - put the relationship tags on the way and delete the relation.

83194530

Hi,
Should not the interval be on the ferry route relations not on the individual segments? Some segments are used by different routes.. thus could be confusing???

179250890

Yay!
Looks like it complies with 'the rules'.

177714931

14 days
no response.

179198542

Hi,
relation/20274479 - heath has a problem Outer ways cannot share segments. see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=169.37918&lat=-45.19754&zoom=19&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=duplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways%2Cduplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways

I'd delete the relation. Then put the tag 'natural=heath' and be done. No need for as relation at all.

179138761

way/1483880053 has a node or 2 that are causing problems...
See way/1483880053

170281222

Name is for name only, not a description eg 'Terrace Houses'.

relation/19448184 deleted - shared segments.

173296133

What is the 'Smallwood Estate'?

Looks to me like these group of building are individual properties that can be purchased individually .. with individual; addresses. Perhaps they were developed as a lot but once sold this 'estate' ceased to be?

In any case the relation has no outer so it does not make OSM sense.

175602552

Deleted relation/19927055 - 2 members both inners.

151169089

Errr No.

Multipolygon outer ways cannot share segments.

In principle the surface parking would be part of the mall too.

I'd put a simple way around the hole outside of the block and put the tags on that .. depending on the OSM definition of 'mall'?
Alternative? Put a simple way around the outside of all of the buildings and tags on that.

Thoughts?