SomeoneElse's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 125998603 | A bit more info - https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1lTh is what was deleted. I'm surprised that there doesn't appear to be a long, linear "natural=mountain_range" feature for the "Cordillera de los Andes", but there do not seem to be any: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1lTi . |
|
| 125998603 | (traducción automática)
> Soy de la comunidad argentina, el cambio se acordó con la comunidad chilena en su momento y ya lo habían eliminado. ¿Sería posible enlazar donde sucedieron esas conversaciones? > Había líneas sin contenido, lo que hice fue borrar eso. Tal vez sea solo un error de traducción, pero relation/13723952/history definitivamente tenía contenido. Siempre es difícil representar características muy grandes como esta con relaciones, formas y nodos detallados; ¿tal vez hubiera sido mejor una "línea de cordillera" más simple?
|
|
| 125998603 | Hello, Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here. > I am from the Argentine community, the change was agreed upon with the Chilean community at the time and had already been eliminated. Would it be possible to link to where those conversations happened? > There were lines without content, what I did was delete that. Maybe it's just a mistranslation, but relation/13723952/history definitely did have content. It's always difficult to represent very large features like this with detailed relations, ways, and nodes - perhaps a simpler "mountain range line" would have been better?
|
|
| 126138882 | Hola joserrg12, Utilice comentarios más descriptivos que simplemente "detalles añadidos". Saludos, Andy |
|
| 126138882 | Hello joserrg12, Please use more descriptive comments than just "added details". Best Regards, Andy |
|
| 126079467 | Yes - but it's quite a long river! It's 1 relation and 8 ways in total. The relation is relation/12906468 - I think that 3 of the northern sections were edited by this mapper.
|
|
| 126079467 | @LockOnGuy This changeset covers areas where the first language varies, so your comment isn't really helpful unless you actually link to the object that was changed, so that everyone can see where it is, and judge for themselves what languages would be appropriate in the name tag. |
|
| 126178662 | OK, done. I undid it with a combination of JOSM's "reverter" plugin and the Perl revert scripts.
|
|
| 126178662 | I'll have a go at undoing it |
|
| 126117914 | Thanks! |
|
| 125494801 | Thanks - fixed |
|
| 126117914 | Er, "contact me in private message for souces" isn't really OK. Please include source details here. |
|
| 126107866 | Oops - forgot to close changeset. There's nothing other than in the very northeast and the very southwest, honest. |
|
| 82447976 | Thanks - I'll sort that out. |
|
| 125817813 | @Pink Duck but it sounds like what you're saying is that in your example the "highway" tag was wrong - it's not just for foot traffic, and so DaveF's "fix" here is incorrect (and has actually made the problem worse)?
|
|
| 125817813 | @DaveF re "you may thank me" above, being a smug git is not helping anyone, especially you. Let's try and work together here and understand each other's point of view. |
|
| 124635259 | Thanks - I was wondering what the "new national park" on https://map.atownsend.org.uk was! |
|
| 125817813 | One situation where "Remove access=private from footways with designation=public_footpath" might be incorrect is where the it's not the access tags that are incorrect but the highway tag. If any of these 44 ways was actually a highway=track, but incorrectly tagged as a highway=footway, then it's the "highway" tag that needs changing, not the "access" tag. |
|
| 125817813 | For completeness, https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1lOm is a shared query that is close to what you might want. All of these are likely mistagged, as the "access=private" on a footway will be overridden by the "foot" tag, and access tags for other modes are assumed to be "no" by default as it's a footway. |
|
| 125817813 | in the case of way/992713995/history , not really - that public footpath (with "foot=designated") has been there since you added it 11 months ago. The "access=private" never had any effect, because it was "highway=footway". |