SomeoneElse's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 126178662 | OK, done. I undid it with a combination of JOSM's "reverter" plugin and the Perl revert scripts.
|
|
| 126178662 | I'll have a go at undoing it |
|
| 126117914 | Thanks! |
|
| 125494801 | Thanks - fixed |
|
| 126117914 | Er, "contact me in private message for souces" isn't really OK. Please include source details here. |
|
| 126107866 | Oops - forgot to close changeset. There's nothing other than in the very northeast and the very southwest, honest. |
|
| 82447976 | Thanks - I'll sort that out. |
|
| 125817813 | @Pink Duck but it sounds like what you're saying is that in your example the "highway" tag was wrong - it's not just for foot traffic, and so DaveF's "fix" here is incorrect (and has actually made the problem worse)?
|
|
| 125817813 | @DaveF re "you may thank me" above, being a smug git is not helping anyone, especially you. Let's try and work together here and understand each other's point of view. |
|
| 124635259 | Thanks - I was wondering what the "new national park" on https://map.atownsend.org.uk was! |
|
| 125817813 | One situation where "Remove access=private from footways with designation=public_footpath" might be incorrect is where the it's not the access tags that are incorrect but the highway tag. If any of these 44 ways was actually a highway=track, but incorrectly tagged as a highway=footway, then it's the "highway" tag that needs changing, not the "access" tag. |
|
| 125817813 | For completeness, https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1lOm is a shared query that is close to what you might want. All of these are likely mistagged, as the "access=private" on a footway will be overridden by the "foot" tag, and access tags for other modes are assumed to be "no" by default as it's a footway. |
|
| 125817813 | in the case of way/992713995/history , not really - that public footpath (with "foot=designated") has been there since you added it 11 months ago. The "access=private" never had any effect, because it was "highway=footway". |
|
| 125817813 | @DaveD Does OutdoorActive route down "highway=footway; foot=yes; access=private"? If it doesn't, that's a bug, and it'd be great if you could badger them to fix it. If not, I'd suggest stopping using that app because it is just broken. |
|
| 125817813 | @Pink Duck Can you please give an example of a way that was adversely affected by this change where mapping that was correct "on the ground" is now incorrect?
|
|
| 126031408 | Hello,
|
|
| 126009172 | Hello,
|
|
| 124635259 | Hello,
|
|
| 126015808 | Thanks.
|
|
| 125907305 | Hello HKHikerhang, You've deleted the peak node/8781290893/history . This seems odd - peaks don't normally disappear! How does that relate to the changeset comment here 'Change to "old_name" for those names not commonly use nowadays'?
|