OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
119429873

Hello,
You've changed way/190020980 from being a path intended for use by people on foot to a path with no obvious intended mode.
Just checking - was that deliberate?
Best Regards,
Andy

119308368

Thanks!

119400601

Re changeset/119400601 ,

It is not OK to revert another user's changeset if that was made in good faith, without any sort of discussion with that user.

Did you have any sort of discussion where they said it was OK for you to revert it?

115368669

Thanks for the extra links above - I'll go through them (and in particular the lat/long info) later.

117056434

> which information was lost ?

My mistake - I didnt spot the pre-existiing "natural=bare_rock" tag.

119341145

"large" is sometimes tricky; something like relation/13325281 is inherently large, so if you're editing it you're going to end up with a "geographically large" changeset.
Also use a helpful changeset comment though!

63454095

Just checking - should way/633304589 be part of relation/358939 ? changeset/119270675 suggests "One gap left where signs missing and route unclear.", which I guess is around way/4333186 , but the "bit of an extra" to the west looks odd: http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=358939

119400684

I used https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1hsj as a source to trim a spur off too.

119327774

Thanks for fixing node/4401259541 , but where was the automatic edit in this changeset discussed?

119241586

Whilst the change of way/244898746/history from "Colonization Road" to "Reconciliation Road" is plausible (many similar roads have been renamed in Canada) no source was provided by PopeyePopcord for this change here. Can someone local provide it?

119319346

Apologies for the "globe-spanning" changeset. The edits reverted here were mostly in Winnipeg in Canada and Australia, with nothing much in between.
To email the DWG about it, use a subject line with "[Ticket#2022033110000019]" in it.
The mapper was repeatedly asked for source information but refused to disclose anything meaningful (see e.g. https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=15467027&commented - "Local Data").

119316695

Hello, what source did you use for this change? The source hasn't changed since the _old_ name.

119316534

Hello again.
What is the source of this data?

119225018

Please be more clear. At what URL did you read this information and under what licence was it made available to you.

119308368

When you say "local knowledge" do you mean that you have personally visited the shop?

119225018

Hello,
What do you mean by "local data"?
Where did you get it from
Best Regards,
Andy

119308368

What is your source for this - local survey, something else?

119308368

Please do reply to the questions that other mappers have asked about the sources of your data.

115368669

OK - one last chance - please explain where you have linked to any "proof" above.

115368669

> to prove i vandalize data.
I believe that you're "vandalising the community" (to use your word);
I don't know the ground truth of way/965429633/history since I have never been there. I also asked you for source details (specifically "What evidence do you have that
way/965429633/history actually exists as something that someone on the ground would think was an actual highway? ") but have received none.