OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
111193816

Thanks

111372930

Hello frank692000,
Irrespective of any other issues raised, please always use changeset comments that explain what you are doing to other mappers, not just something like "add road" every time.
Best Regards,
Andy

111304963

Hello,
I've just filled in a gap in the Cleveland Way - can you check changeset/111341520 to make sure that I've understood what E2 is doing here?
Best Regards,
Andy

111280963

Thanks!

108759112

Thanks. Will you take other imagery layers into account for future edits?

110321179

Thanks. Rather than just "fix tag" here I'd have said "added area=yes tag to Burnham Pier so that it is recognised as an area feature rather than a linear one".

111285085

From looking at the history relation/6058814/history , it looks like it was originally "no U turn from way/173696670 back on to itself", which does make sense. I don't understand why another mapper changed it in changeset/37893249 - maybe you could ask them, or maybe they just made a mistake? Looking through their earlier changes in this area, such as changeset/37893189 , they did explicitly add some "no U turn" relations (that changeset has the comment "Demi-tour interdit".

111193816

Thanks. What should the changeset comment have been?

111280963

Should there be a relation that forces you to go straight on if you're coming from the southeast?
If so, to fix the problem you'd need to re-add that, not just to delete the invalid relation.

111261949

Thanks!

111193816

I'm confused that you've either (a) just used the wrong changeset comment or (b) you're copying data from an external site that includes data that isn't licence-compatible with OSM (your Arcgis site claims a source of "Esri UK, Esri, HERE, Garmin, INCREMENT P, USGS").

111131245

Also, please talk to your colleague at changeset/108759112 .
Best Regards,
Andy

108759112

Hello,
Half of way/968168182 looks sensible but have does not. Have a look at OS OpenMap Local to see what I mean. I'd also suggest talking to your colleague at changeset/111131245 .
Best Regards,
Andy

111131245

Hello,
I think you've got the barrier in the wrong place here. Have a look at the OS OpenMap Local Imagery from April this year.
Best Regards,
Andy

104130479

@Thomas Jarvis NastassiaKalesnikava has not replied, so I'd just revert this to what you know to be correct if I were you.

109076919

There clearly _is_ something there. I've updated in changeset/109825114#map=19/53.99148/-1.05755 based on what I can see from New Lane.

111280963

You've deleted the relation here, but from looking at https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1be3 it's easy to see what the original mapper intended. Are you sure that there really is no relation here, or did you delete it because it was currently invalid (last edited by your Mapbox colleague DzmitryBachkarou 3 months ago)?

110622595

Hello,
Can you explain what a "bag update" is please?
Best Regards,
Andy

111240687

Hello ZhannaB,
Please don't use just "correction" as a changeset comment - please explain what you changed and why, and what the source was
Best Regards,
Andy

110900081

Hello vinevzorova,
Please use more meaningful changeset comments that simply "fixed the name".
Best Regards,
Andy