Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Hello mdavenport1985,
There are at least a couple of problems with this changeset - node/5211700721/history appears to be a duplicate node of node/4445118202/history . Also there seems to be nothing in the Bing imagery to suggest that the unclassified roads such as way/538436766 that you added in changeset/53520335 actually exist.
Please don't add things to OpenStreetMap that don't exist - it devalues the work of everyone else.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

Hi,
not sure how it happened but node/5211235151/history is a "duplicate node" of node/2326986287/history which was created 4 years ago. Assuming these streets actually join, they should share nodes, and you can move fro one to the other.
Hope this makes sense - any questions please don't hesitate to ask.
Best Regards,
Andy

Follow-on from changeset/53501753 (which hit 10k objects)

Hello mdavenport1985,
As previously mentioned, I think that you're still "overinterpreting" aerial imagery somewhat. For example, I don't believe that way/538277195 is all building (note that there's no defined shadow to the south) whereas way/538277196 is a building. Also, these two buildings as drawn overlap (which clearly makes no sense) and you have node/5210393047 as an overlapping node in the other corner.
Please slow down a bit, look at all of the available imagery sources and ask for help if you need it.
Also, as mentioned on osm.org/user_blocks/1615 , please do engage with other mappers.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

Hi,
Is node/4957653990 best described as a tourism=information? I presume that it's not actually accessible, being sat on the White House roof - presumably I'd attract a fair bit of attention if I tried to go up there.
It sounds like it's something more like a man_made=survey_point , perhaps?
Best Regards,
Andy

Yes - what SK53 has said is correct. It's probably clearer to look at some of the other examples in the same file (barriers, shops, offices). For example, depending on the application it might make sense to render or otherwise process a cycle_barrier the same as a motorcycle_barrier or it absolutely might not.

Hello,
Please be aware that there are two nodes here - one for the town node/599019138 and one for the province node/2914855220 . You've just changed the province one to place=town. Please be careful, especially when editing with OsmAnd (which will have fairly out of date data in it). As you can see from http://osm.mapki.com/history/node.php?id=599019138 there have been lots of recent changes here.
Best Regards,
Andy

Hello,
"fixed wrong name and added info" doesn't really explain what you changed here or why. If you'd said "changed name from version with '/' in it to the same as name:ckb, which is by far the most common used language here" that would explain things better to everyone.

Hello,
way/535073780 overlaps way/423968288 that was added a year ago.
Best Regards,
Andy

Hello,
way/535616453 overlaps way/426382206 that was added a year ago. There are some other similar overlaps nearby.
Best Regards,
Andy

Also way/535984187
overlaps
way/531282011 .

Hello,
way/508436188 overlaps way/407586677 .
Presumably something went wrong when you were uploading it?
Best Regards,
Andy

Hello, building way/507733122 overlaps
way/507403088 .Presumably something went wrong with the upload?
Best Regards,
Andy

@harcher "batches are also cleaned against existing OSM data before uploading to prevent duplication and overlap (i.e., areas with previously drawn structures). "
This hasn't happened in a number of places, such as changeset/53283139 . I commented there 7 days ago; there was no response from the mapper. Some of these edits are of such poor quality that we'll likely have to revert the changes.

Hello,
Please don't add test data to the live OpenStreetMap Server. If you want a test server, perhaps https://master.apis.dev.openstreetmap.org/ would work for you?
Best Regards,
Andy