OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
48122711

Hello,
Can you explain the reason for the building deletions in here such as way/42558687/history ? That still exists on the imagery. Has it really been demolished?
Best Regards,
Andy

45729080

Hi,
I'd suggest actually checking these in a bit more detail before you mechanically edit them - node/4300814810/history is clearly just garbage (and was the subject of a previous revert).
Cheers,
Andy

48087689

Just for info I've added a 0-hour block at osm.org/user_blocks/1328 and reverted to the pre-edit-war situation in changeset/48114086 .

40027234

Er, OK....

In http://overpass-turbo.eu/ if I click "wizard", type in "pub" and "build query" I get http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/oBt which searches for amenity=pub on nodes, ways and relations.

Can you explain where you got the idea that POIs should be mapped as nodes from? I'm genuinely curious - OSM's documentation can be a bit contradictory, and if there's something that suggests that tags such as "amenity=pub" should only be on nodes it could do to be changed.
Best Regards,
Andy

47403489

Hi,
I've already done it in changeset/47953850 .
Thanks,
Andy

47981886

Again, to be clear, _layer tags are relative_. Layer 0 does _not_ imply ground level.
Again, what _actual problem_ are you trying to solve?

47947482

Firstly - please take the wiki with a bucketload of salt :)
Secondly - layer=0 doesn't imply ground level - layer tags are relative, so "All bridges need a layer tag of 1 or higher" is simply wrong.
Also, although it is possible to infer relative level from imagery and other sources, it's also possible to get it wrong - it's especially problematic where there are multiple layer items in the same place.
How much time did you spend checking these 1924 items? Did you actually visit any of the more complicated ones to see things from ground level?
Failing to do that makes this a mechanical edit, which means that you should have followed osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct and discussed the changes that you were going to do first.
Best Regards,
Andy

40027234

Please don't duplicate data - if something you're using to search for pubs doesn't find pubs mapped as ways it'll miss a lot of pubs (roughly a third in the UK - http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org.uk/tags/amenity=pub )

43583909

It's OK; I've reverted them.
Thanks,
Andy

48007382

Hello,
In this changeset you've changed the name of this place from the Armenian name to to an anglicized version of the the Azerbaijani name.
Your changeset comment "Something wrong explained" unfortunately does not explain what the problem was and why you changed it.
Could you explain the reason behind this change?
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OpenStreetMap's Data Working Group.

47981886

Can you explain what you mean by "invalid layer tag"?
Layer tags are relative, so "layer=-1" or "layer=-100" isn't any more valid or invalid than "layer=0" or an implied layer=0, if all crossing features have positive layer tags.
What problem are you trying to solve?
Best Regards,
Andy

43583909

Hello,
Please don't add test data to the live OpenStreetMap Server. If you want a test server, perhaps https://master.apis.dev.openstreetmap.org/ would work for you?
Best Regards,
Andy

47992495

Oops - you've added this one-node building in the middle of the Atlantic at latitude 0, longitude 0. I guess that this means that OsmAnd didn't have a valid location when you added it?
Best Regards,
Andy

46849184

Thanks Brian - and yay for email appearing!

46849184

Thanks Brian.
Just one question - @wmca doesn't seem to be a valid account?
Best Regards,
Andy

47924997

Hello,
In this edit you've deleted the clothes shop that was downstairs - changeset/47924997 - was that deliberate?
Best Regards,
Andy

47434147

Unfortunately this "fake park" that you deleted here was actually a school originally!

way/23646951/history

I've reverted it and patched it up with P1.

Best Regards,
Andy

47784601

@mueschel no reply here so I've reverted these additions and sent the user a message that they have to read before continuing editing: osm.org/user_blocks/1320 .
Best Regards,
Andy

47930917

Thanks - I've undeleted it in changeset/47952895 .

47930917

Er,
You've deleted the weather buoy at node/3815077900/history
Was this intentional?
Best Regards,
Andy