OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
133692132

Olá,
Andy do Grupo de Trabalho de Dados aqui novamente.
Independentemente de onde o museu esteja, o usuário que agora se autodenomina "volredman" pode realmente fornecer evidências de um _edifício_ neste local:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1srK ?
Todas as imagens compatíveis com OSM que posso ver sugerem que há um grande pilar do outro lado do caminho da estátua de Pelé, mas nenhum edifício.
Para ser claro, houve problemas com edições de ambos os lados desta disputa - um errou os nomes de algumas ruas (consulte https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=360183) mas o outro foi culpado de vandalismo óbvio (consulte changeset/133644351) e cópia do Google.
Atenciosamente,
Andy Townsend, em nome do Grupo de Trabalho de Dados da OSM.

133692132

Hello,
Andy from the Data Working Group here again.
Regardless of where the museum is, can the user now calling themselves "volredman" actually provide evidence of a _building_ at this location:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1srK ?
All the OSM-compatible imagery that I can see suggests that there is a large pillar the other side of the path from the statue of Pele, but no building.
To be clear, there have been issues with edits by both sides of this dispute - one has got the names of some streets wrong (see https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=360183 ) but the other has been guilty of obvious vandalism (see changeset/133644351 ) and copying from Google.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

133639567

Thanks

133639567

Hello,
There have been a number of reports (from different accounts, but quite possibly the same person) that IBGE is wrong here. Do you have on-the ground sources to corroborate these names? Survey, Mapilliary, that sort of thing?
Best Regards,
Andy

133668936

Hello,
I've moved a bit of footpath from the England Coast Path Superrelation relation/3971851 to the local relation here relation/14247952 .
It (like most other big relation) is split into pieces because the whole thing would be just too big to manage otherwise.
Best Regards,
Andy

133515662

Thanks

133506932

For info, I'm currently in communication with the "Endereços e lugares" account asking them to answer questions such as the above, initially via email to the DWG. They have said many times "My account has been wrongly suspended!" but I'm still waiting for direct answers to the questions that have been asked.

133515662

Hello,
What was the source of the name here? A previous editor has shared a photo showing "Rua Cônego José Lorêto" (somewhere).
Best Regards,
Andy

133635681

It is, but almost any update to OpenStreetMap is a "data update"!
Here, as we can see from https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/242337151 you've removed the name of "18" which didn't match the addr:housenumber of 16.
I'm sure that that's absolutely fine - but a little bit of a description beyond "data update" would be really helpful!

133635681

Please use more descriptive changeset comments.

127474250

Hello again,
Just wondered what prompted the change to Lendal Cellars https://osm.mapki.com/history/node/246525501 here? Was it a survey, or was the editor you were using suggesting that the previous tags were incorrect?
The reason that I ask is that GK-operated pubs aren't always branded GK - some are, some aren't, and if something is telling you to add that tag without a survey that thing is wrong.
Best Regards,
Andy

133601658

Please try and use a better changeset comment than "updated data".

133506932

Mais uma coisa - por favor, use descrições melhores de suas alterações do que "Upgrade realizado". Explique o que você mudou e por que mudou, e qual foi a fonte dessa mudança.

133506932

One more thing - please use better descriptions of your changes than "Upgrade realizado". Explain what you changed and why you changed it, and what your source for that change was.

133506932

Olá, Andy Townsend do Grupo de Trabalho de Dados da OSM aqui.
Pode "Endereços e lugares", ou um de seus "amigos", fornecer evidências reais de que o nome "Viaduto Nelson Daiha" aqui não está correto? Já vimos um link do wille, a maioria que carrega pra mim na Europa, mas nada do outro lado (além de https://globoplay.globo.com/v/5422883/ , que não carrega).
Atenciosamente,
andy

133506932

Hello, Andy Townsend from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can "Endereços e lugares", or one of their "friends" please provide actual evidence that the "Viaduto Nelson Daiha" name here is not correct? We've already seen a link from wille, most of which loads for me in Europe, but nothing from the other side (other than https://globoplay.globo.com/v/5422883/ , which does not).
Best Regards,
Andy

126890260

مرحبا الوند ،
ليس من المقبول اختلاق أسماء لقطع عشب كهذه. لقد أزلت الأسماء.
أطيب التحيات،
آندي تاونسند ، نيابة عن مجموعة عمل البيانات في OSM.

126890260

سڵاو ئەڵوەند،
باش نییە ناوی پارچە چیمەنێک بەم شێوەیە دروست بکەیت. ناوەکانم لابردووە.
لەگەڵ ڕێز,
ئەندی تاونسێند، بەناوی گروپی کاری داتاکانی OSM.

126890260

Hello Alwand,
It's not OK to make up names for pieces of grass like this. I have removed the names.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

133404353

Привіт Телвін!
Ваш коментар до набору змін тут просто "актуалізація даних" ("оновлення даних"). Це не допомагає іншим користувачам зрозуміти, які дані ви змінили та чому. У майбутньому, будь ласка, використовуйте більш описові коментарі до набору змін.
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді Таунсенд, від імені робочої групи даних OSM.