OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
114310507

Previously part of Tower Bridge Road and two parts of Decima Street were part of the multipolygon. This didn't look right - most importantly because the imagery shows Tower Bridge Road as quite wide here and the pedestrian area much narrower than previously drawn.
Also the packaging of the outside roads into a multipolygon meant as far as I can see they were no longer valid geometrical objects in their own right - I was seeing one (arguably correctly) not shown and one (arguably in error) appear.
What's missing now I suspect is the "logical linear footway" through the pedestrian area, and where it connects to the sidewalk (or perhaps a crossing) to the south, and the connections to the crossings at east and northeast.

102066738

> But my decision is partly based on experience gained when hiking in this locality.
That's great! If you're familiar with the local conditions then yes - you'll have a pretty good idea what the tracktype is.

109484665

(після відповіді, отриманої в приватні повідомлення)

Важливо відповісти на публічний коментар обговорення набору змін у самому обговоренні набору змін, щоб кожен, хто бачить вихідне запитання, також міг побачити відповідь.

Відповідь на загальнодоступне повідомлення в додатку для приватних повідомлень, наприклад Telegram, також не є гарною, тому що лише кілька людей зможуть його побачити.

Будь ласка, дайте відповідь тут.

109484665

(following up a reply received by private message)

It's important to reply to a public changeset discussion comment in the changeset discussion itself, so that everyone who can see the original question can also see the answer.

A reply to a public message in a private messaging app such as Telegram is also not good, because only a few people will be able to see it.

Please reply here.

102066738

I was just a bit surprised that you'd be able to set the "tracktype" from that.

107276082

... and of course you still need to do the things that you were asked to do at osm.org/user_blocks/5479 .

107276082

Hello VARVAR8,
Thanks for your reply.
Unfortunately the scale of the problem is such that I don't think that it's physically possible for you do do that.
An overpass query http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1dvN covers a relatively small area of Ukraine and includes 1332 ways all added by you with an unfeasible tracktype. Many, like the example above, will presumably not be tracks at all but have multiple problems - not only has the wrong sort of feature been added, but in the wrong place (there's a clear offset between whatever poor-quality imagery that MapWithAI is using and the best available at osm.org).

> As you can see from my previous sets, I later revise the lines I have implemented and, if necessary, correct them

What I can see from your later edits is that you only "correct" very few problems and still miss lots of errors.

Can you please explain what process you are going to use to fix the errors that you have created. If you can't explain that effectively, we'll have no option to revert your erroneous additions (to be clear, the DWG has had a number of requests from the community in Ukraine asking us to do this).
Best Regards,
Andy

107276082

Здравствуйте,
Чи можете ви пояснити, з чого ви отримали теги на way/960173443/history? У коментарі до набору змін немає корисної інформації, яка могла б пояснити, як ви думали, що це шосе = траса, не важливо tracktype=grade3. Дивлячись на зображення, а особливо на геометрію довколишніх шляхів, це більше схоже на водний шлях=потік, ніж на шосе=колію, а tracktype=grade3 — чиста фантазія.
Поясніть, будь ласка, процес, за допомогою якого ви його додали.
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді

107276082

Hello,
Can you explain what your source of the tags on way/960173443/history was? There is no useful information in the changeset comment that might explain how you thought that it was a highway=track, never mind tracktype=grade3. Looking at the imagery, and especially the geometry of the nearby ways, it looks more like a waterway=stream than a highway=track, and the tracktype=grade3 is pure fantasy.
Please explain the process by which you added it.
Best Regards,
Andy

102109790

Здравствуйте,
Чи можете ви пояснити, яке було ваше джерело для tracktype=grade3 на way/924728247/history?
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді

102109790

Hello,
Can you explain what your source for tracktype=grade3 on way/924728247/history was please?
Best Regards,
Andy

102066738

Здравствуйте,
Чи можете ви пояснити, яке джерело для tracktype на way/924419212/history було, будь ласка?
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді

102066738

Hello,
Can you explain what your source for tracktype on way/924419212/history was please?
Best Regards,
Andy

72432998

Здравствуйте,
Чи можете ви пояснити, яке джерело для tracktype було на way/705759141/history, будь ласка?
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді

72432998

Hello,
Can you explain what your source for tracktype was on way/705759141/history please?
Best Regards,
Andy

109484665

Здравствуйте,
Ви додали тут way/972101687/history як "highway=track; tracktype=grade3", але, дивлячись на основні зображення, це виглядає як повна фантазія. На зображеннях Maxar мало що б передбачало будь-який вид треку; як вам вдалося визначити, що це «tracktype=grade3», я поняття не маю.
Схоже, що нам доведеться видалити всі ваші доповнення цього типу, але спочатку дотримуйтесь порад на osm.org/user_blocks/5479.
З найкращими побажаннями,
Енді (з робочої групи з даних OSM)

109484665

Hello,
You've added way/972101687/history as a "highway=track; tracktype=grade3" here, but looking at the underlying imagery, this looks like a complete fantasy. There is little on the Maxar imagery that would suggest any sort of track; how you managed to determine that it was "tracktype=grade3" I have no idea.
It's looking increasingly like we'll need to delete all of your additions of this type, but please follow the advice at osm.org/user_blocks/5479 first.
Best Regards,
Andy (from OSM's Data Working Group)

114294193

Hello NTmapperz,
Please use meaningful changeset comments, not just ".", so that people can understand what you are editing.
Best Regards,
Andy

113491414

way/972101460/history було додано як трек grade3, а потім змінено на потік!
Ви можете пояснити, що тут сталося?

113491414

way/972101460/history was added as a grade3 track, and then changed to a stream!
Can you explain what happened here?