OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
110658249

The criteria isn't "does it have wikidata" (many, many things have wikidata but no Chinese name), but "does it have a Chinese name". It's reasonable to assume that all countries have a verifiable Chinese name (and a name in most other common languages) but not reasonable to assume that every hamlet or small town does.
According to https://www.ethnologue.com/ there are over 7000 languages in the world. 85000000 things in OSM have a name: https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/name . Most things in OSM only have one name, so adding 7000 extra tags for those names that form part of every database extract would take up 7000 times more space - it would make handling OpenStreetMap data impractical for everyone.

110658249

Hello,
That just looks like a transliteration then, and doesn't really belong in OSM. See osm.wiki/Names#Avoid_transliteration for more details.
Best Regards,
Andy

110710157

The changesets added by StreetComplete are under control of the app, not the user. It groups changes by category not by location, so people might make more than one change in a location.
If you think that that could be improved, the place to talk about it is at https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete/issues .
It's not OK for your first communication with a user in a changeset discussion to be "STOP IT!!!" - they'll see that message emailed to them, and without any context won't even know what they are supposed to stop or why.
As I've already said elsewhere, I think that you owe this user an apology.

109747676

A worldwide edit where the changeset is on 11 objects doesn't seem unreasonable to me, and it also seems like an obvious "typo fix" that really doesn't need a prior discussion - (where the name is Chinese) it's obviously wrong. There's an argument that the extra language names on way/39297336/history might not match reality, or might just be transliterations or descriptions, but that's a discussion to be had with the mapper that added them.
Best Regards,
Andy

110658249

你好快乐的老鼠宝宝,
你在这里更名的来源是什么? 另外,请不要使用“修复名称”的变更集描述,因为它没有解释您为什么要更改它以及源是什么。
此致,
Andy Townsend,代表 OSM 的数据工作组。

110658249

Hello 快乐的老鼠宝宝,
What is the source of your name change here? Also, please just don't use a changeset description of "Fix Name" because it doesn't explain why you are changing it and what the source is.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

106547372

Bonjour bide2,
Veuillez ne pas ajouter de noms "descriptifs" comme "noms". Pour plus d'informations, consultez osm.wiki/FR:Names#Name_est_juste_le_nom . way/813894649 contient la balise "access=private", ce que verront les personnes utilisant les données. Aucun routeur ne comprendra qu'il ne doit pas utiliser "name=Accès interdit - Bois et chemins privés".
Meilleures salutations,
Andy

106547372

Hello bide2,
Please don't add "descriptive" names as "names". For more information see osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only . way/813894649 has the tag "access=private" tag on it, which is what people using the data will see. No router will understand that they should not use "name=Accès interdit - Bois et chemins privés".
Best Regards,
Andy

110710157

Why is that a problem?

110710157

@Hanan Tikveša What is the problem with this change? It's created on the fly by StreetComplete - are you saying that it is incorrect and the crossing barriers are incorrectly mapped now?

86638050

안녕하십니까,
여기 OSM 데이터 워킹 그룹의 Andy가 있습니다.
여기에 변경의 원인이 무엇인지 설명할 수 있습니까?
친애하는,
앤디

86638050

Hello,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can you explain what the source of your change is here?
Best Regards,
Andy

107876555

안녕하십니까,
여기 OSM 데이터 워킹 그룹의 Andy가 있습니다.
여기에 변경의 원인이 무엇인지 설명할 수 있습니까?
친애하는,
앤디

107876555

Hello,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can you explain what the source of your change is here?
Best Regards,
Andy

109564039

안녕하십니까,
여기 OSM 데이터 워킹 그룹의 Andy가 있습니다.
여기에 변경의 원인이 무엇인지 설명할 수 있습니까?
친애하는,
앤디

109564039

Hello,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can you explain what the source of your change is here?
Best Regards,
Andy

102624155

안녕하십니까,
여기 OSM 데이터 워킹 그룹의 Andy가 있습니다.
여기에 변경의 원인이 무엇인지 설명할 수 있습니까?
친애하는,
앤디

102624155

Hello,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can you explain what the source of your change is here?
Best Regards,
Andy

90552882

안녕하세요 YxY KIM
여기 OSM 데이터 워킹 그룹의 Andy가 있습니다.
여기에 변경의 원인이 무엇인지 설명할 수 있습니까?
친애하는,
앤디

90552882

Hello YxY KIM,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here.
Can you explain what the source of your change is here?
Best Regards,
Andy