Changeset When Comment
146651421

I'm familiar with the area, but have used the Esri imagery here (less tree cover) to help trace the bed.

60786314

(oops - forgot to also link node/11194634525 and https://map.atownsend.org.uk/tmp/175024.jpg )

60786314

I'm guessing it's just someone with a bag full of stickers and a bit of wishful thinking - a bit like the "Camino Ingles to Santiago" (sic) at relation/14638771 . Obviously there are dozens of "official" Camino routes (see e.g. https://caminoways.com/camino-ingles ) but those stickers in Yorkshire don't match anything that I've found on the internet. I suspect that your "Jerusalem Way" might be similar.

60786314

There are references to "a sticker" at https://threepointsofthecompass.com/2022/02/12/trail-talk-the-miners-way/ . No idea if you can tell whether that sticker is yours!
I suspect that the Jerusalem Way being referred to in that article is https://www.jerusalemway.org/en/route/ , which I guess someone could "extend" into Kent...

86143474

I'm guessing that perhaps relation/11167888/history shouldn't be "historic=ty", but what should it be?

82209929

Another puzzle - "historic=tower" on relation/10837218/history seems unlikely - or have I just misunderstood what it is?

75320271

Hello,
should "historic=sou" on relation/10117075/history perhaps be "historic=yes"?
Best Regards,
Andy

146530302

Thanks!

145540046

Hello meongseolin,

I changed the admin level of Somaliland from 2 to 3 previously, so I can answer this.

The way that disputed territories are handled in OSM can be seen at https://osmfoundation.org/w/images/d/d8/DisputedTerritoriesInformation.pdf . When we last discussed the status of Somaliland, there were things in its favour (largely economically independent from Somalia) and things against (recognised as independent by almost no-one internationally).

Before we make top-level changes to things like this, it’s important to discuss them - https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/general/38/none would be a good place to do that.

Best Regards,
Andy (from OSM's Data Working Group)

146509566

Also ts0608b, ts0617b

145662783

I've checked - there's nothing here.

135323508

See https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/language-used-in-uae-names-of-towns-cities-wadis-mountains-etc-the-law-requires-that-they-be-recorded-in-arabic-english/108270

90866934

See forum thread https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/someones-added-building-plots-as-buildings/101306

145366078

szia d zsolt!
Először is – ez a módosításkészlet eltávolította a tagi módokat a 23096-ból – ezt láthatja, ha az alábbi "osmChange XML"-re kattint, és megnézi az XML végét. Látható, hogy az utolsó néhány kapcsolatnak nincsenek tagjai.
Ez persze nem magyarázza meg a történteket. Biztos vagyok benne, hogy nem volt rosszindulatú (tehát a balint36 erre vonatkozó javaslatai nem hasznosak), de valami elromlott, és ha nem próbálja meg kideríteni, hogy mi volt az, előfordulhat, hogy újra megtörténik.
Amikor feltölt a JOSM-mel, összefoglalót kap arról, hogy mit változtatott. Talán segítene, ha gyakrabban töltenéd fel, kevesebb változtatással az egyes changesetekben?
Üdvözlettel,
Andy

145366078

Hello zsolt d,
First things first - this changeset did remove the member ways from 23096 - you can see that by clicking on the "osmChange XML" below and looking at the end of the XML. You can see that the last few relations have no members.
This doesn't of course, explain what happened. I'm sure that it was not malicious (so suggestions of that by balint36 aren't helpful) but something did go wrong, and if you don't try and find out what that was, it might happen again.
When you upload with JOSM you do get a summary of what you've changed. Maybe it would help to upload more often with fewer changes in each changeset?
Best Regards,
Andy

60786314

Thanks!

139677537

You've also left "note:opening_hours:covid19" while deleting the tag that it refers to, which doesn't make a lot of sense.

139677537

way/168771637 has also closed and reopened under a different name.

139677537

Are you sure that node/313156653 is open? It didn't look it. See note/4068353 .

45835547

Hello - relation/6950474/history is a bit short of an international route? Was it perhaps something else?
Best Regards, Andy