Changeset When Comment
142933152

In changeset/142961515 I've also changed https://osm.mapki.com/history/relation/2814125 to the new name; that had got changed by Barroszt in changeset/142865556 as well.

142933152

Дякуємо за повторне додавання правильних нових назв до Багринова вулиця (переписка https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/how-about-limit-new-accounts/101656/233). Я також повторно додав сюди old_name:ru, оскільки це _було_ дійсне ім’я до перейменування, яке відбулося після торішнього російського вторгнення в Україну.

142933152

Thanks for re-adding the correct new names to Багринова вулиця (following https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/how-about-limit-new-accounts/101656/233 ). I've also re-added old_name:ru here since it _was_ a valid name before the renaming that happened after last year's Russian invasion of Ukraine.

142852663

I've hidden political comments by a blocked user (that Andrey_91177 replied to) above.

142834734

I've hidden political comments by a blocked user (that NorthCrab replied to) above.

142838820

You are not "adding information". You have removed lots of names.

142670283

For the benefit of anyone stumbling over just this changeset, see also https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2023-October/030791.html

142670251

Someone's started a thread on the mailing list: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2023-October/030791.html

142670251

Regardless of how they were added, and separately from whether I personally think they're a good idea or not, it makes sense to discuss whether they should be there or not. Taking an example, https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/osm-deep-history/#/node/597395247 shows that the story is fairly complicated.
In the case of GB edits, the best place to discuss is the talk-gb mailing list as it'll reach most people.
It should also be mentioned that mass removing or mass-changing tags automatically added by the most popular OSM editor is clearly silly without changing that editor; they will only get re-added.
Best Regards,
Andy

142668293

Yes it is:
https://www.loc.gov/standards/iso639-2/php/langcodes_name.php?iso_639_1=hy
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/name%3Ahy#overview

142668293

Do you mean Armenian here? If ao, that is normally "hy", and I am very suprised that there is not a _current_ name in that language.

4554251

Not easily, as it's not as local to me as it was 13 years ago(!). I probably added a fixme then because what I wrote down didn't match OS OpenData StreetView. It could be that the signage then said "Batewood", or that I wrote it down wrong, or it might even be inconsistent at each end (there are plenty of examples of that round here). If a local has contacted you and said "the name here is X" I'd believe them.

139499598

osm.org/user_blocks/15170

142605379

Perhaps osm.wiki/Relations_are_not_categories is relevant here?

142584942

Hello,
I've filled in the gap in the AONB here with way/1215788024 , following the hedge like - hope that's OK. If you know that the AONB follows a different line (perhaps west of the houses altogether, or down Pump Lane) then please do correct it!
Best Regards,
Andy

142548318

Thanks

141932746

Cześć,
Tutaj Andy z Grupy Roboczej ds. Danych OSM. To, że istnieje oficjalny dokument, nie oznacza, że rozpoczęto budowę drogi. I odwrotnie, to, że zdjęcia lotnicze sugerują, że budowa drogi jeszcze się nie rozpoczęła, nie oznacza, że tak się nie stało – zdjęcia lotnicze mogą być nieaktualne.
Sugeruję, aby jedno lub oboje z was faktycznie odwiedzili to miejsce i wzięli telefon (możesz to łatwo zrobić i dołączyć do notatki OSM za pomocą StreetComplete).
W ten sposób dowiemy się tego na pewno.

141932746

Hello,
Andy from OSM's Data Working Group here. Just because an official document exists, it does not mean that road construction has started. Conversely, just because aerial imagery suggests that road construction has not started yet it doesn't mean that it hasn't - the aerial imagery may be out of date.
I'd suggest that one or both of you actually visits the place and takes a phone (you can do this easily, and append to an OSM note, with StreetComplete).
That way, we will know for sure.

10473529

Great, thanks!

142378596

Great, thanks!