OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
57254988

Hello. You moved the bus stop about 35 meters from the reported ministry of transportation position. Are you sure this is correct?

60401550

שלום ותודה על העריכות. נא להימנע מהוספת פרסומות למפה. תודה.

59288455

אני מסכים שזה לא סטנדרטי - במובן שלרוב לא משתמשים בזה כאן. בכל מקרה אני מציע לך לדון בזה בפורום.
.
אני לא רואה סיבה למה לתת טיפול מיוחד אך ורק לתחנות האוטובוס. אם באמת יוחלט שצריך סטנדרזציה, ניתן לעשות שינוי גלובלי לכל השמות במפה, כולל התחנות.
.
לי אישית העניין לא מפריע. יש בעייתיות במצב הנוכחי?

59288455

משרד התחבורה*

59288455

יש לציין שאי אפשר לשנות שמות תחנות אוטובוס מיובאות. סקריפט הייבוא כבר דרס לך את השמות והחזיר את השם המקורי.
.
השם של תחנת אוטובוס מהווה מידע רשמי שנמצא בשימוש בכל האפליקציות והשירותים אחרים, כולל מערכת הכריזה באוטובוס ומידע על מסכים דיגיטלים בתחנות.
.
כדי לשנות שם, יש לשנות אותו קודם במאגר מידע התחבורה על ידי יצירת קשר איתם. הסקריפט ייבא את השם החדש אוטומטית.
.
מידע נוסף: osm.wiki/User:SafwatHalaby/scripts/gtfs

29710467

Hello. You've added a stop (node/3416365928) which is not present in the Ministry of Transportation data. However, there's a similar stop slightly north of here (node/5210715407). Do you think that's a duplicate? Or are these two separate stops?

59700642

Hello Ynhockey! Your name change to node/1803011231 (bus stop ref: 54) has been automatically reverted by the bus stop update script.
.
The reason behind this is explained in osm.wiki/User:SafwatHalaby/scripts/gtfs#Limited_name_tag_editing

55494104

Hello, this is another edit where you moved a bus stop a large distance. Are you sure this is correct?
.
node/1803002972

54375306

Hello, in this edit, you have moved a bus stop hundreds of meters from the reported Ministry of Transportation position. Are you sure it's correct?
.
node/5210707648

57792287

Hello and welcome to OSM. It appears you have moved some bus stops and roads into unreasonable locations. You've also added nonexisting points of interest.
.
Could you refrain from editing the map further before discussing the reasoning behind your edits?

58623140

Hello! In this edit, you have moved a bus stop. But it is now 400 meters away from the Ministry of Transportation data.
.
Are you sure this is correct?

58785949

There won't be a dispute. I am not strongly in favor of a particular tagging method. I merely wanted to point out that highway=path + footway=crossing is not correct.
.
I do agree that highway=footway and bicycle=yes can be a bit messy, and while "any tag you like" is allowed, it is usually recommended to use established tags, and one needs to check how the new tags affect different editors / viewers.
.
Are there well-established alternatives to highway=footway, footway=crossing, bicycle=dismount?

58785949

On a more general note, I am not sure the global community agrees that highway=path equals highway=footway + bicycle=yes.
.
A footway is mainly for people, it may or may not allow bikes. A path is generic.
.
The way crossings are tagged (they are mainly footways) exemplifies this. there is a footway=crossing tag but no path=crossing tag.

58785949

I am referring to highway=crossing nodes linked with a way which has both highway=footway and footway=crossing. After your edits, the way now has highway=path, footway=crossing which is invalid tagging. See: footway=crossing

This has occurred in older bulk edits too. I think you simply need to exclude ways that also carry footway=crossing or that are connected to highway=crossing nodes.

Take a look at the main streets in Daliat el carmel for instance. most crossings were affected.
osm.org/#map=14/32.6896/35.0607

58766991

e.g. node/925551615

58766991

wikipedia=en:קבוצת דלק does not make sense. I think you meant wikipedia=he: קבוצת דלק

58785949

As discussed earlier, these edits seem to be bad for crossings.

57536223

Hello. The "name" tags in Israel should usually be Hebrew.
.
way/49618415

53507357

I have confirmed there are bugs in certain cases. This includes this, from the latest update: node/1803036633

I will not run further gtfs updates until I fix the issue.

55307717

When moving a stop a small distance (e.g. to the other side of the road), the ref and name tag probably don't need changing.