Hi,
I see that you requested a review. The changeset is very good, the level of detail on the building is great and you used a perfectly descriptive changeset comment.
When mapping buildings in iD editor, you can select a building and press Q. That will make all corners rectangular, which makes the mapping more precise.
Thanks and happy mapping!

Hello,
you requested a review. This changeset is in general very good. When mapping houses in ID, you can select a building and press Q, which will make the corners rectangular.

Happy mapping!

Hello,
thank you for your edit!
To make it easier for other mappers to immediately understand what you did, please take the time and write proper changeset comments.
Her is more info on that: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Thank you!

Hello, I cant tell what natural = BRIDGE HO means on node/12880642514 (the power pole on that property). It seems like a copy and paste error but I am not sure, so I didnt want to just remove it. Can you please clarify it? It seems odd that natural would be used on a human made object.
Thanks!
Jonas

Feel free to look at way/234001304 when you miss it 😅

Hello,
Thank you for adding all those details!
Please note that natural=tree can only be used on individual nodes, not on areas or ways. I fixed this here and at the cementary a few days ago.

Thanks and happy mapping!

Guten Morgen,

War es beabsichtigt, die Tags für Bäume zum Weg way/165438136 hinzuzufügen? Ich verstehe nicht ganz, wie dieses Objekt gemeint ist.

Grundsätzlich sollte der Tag natural=tree nur auf einzelne nodes angewendet werden.

Hello Michael,
please read osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer and reconsider the tags you use in the edits.
A tree with name=farm is not the right way to map anything. In addition, information like a property owners name is not suitable for openstreetmap.

Thank you and happy mapping!

Vespucci didn't close the changeset after I added the landcover in colorado because the api call timed out, so when I did the dog tag edit, it just added it to the same changeset.

Danke für den Hinweis, die hatte ich übersehen, weil sie nicht direkt an der Straße liegen. Werde ich gleich nachreichen!

Hello,
Thank you for your contribution! In the future, please make sure to use more descriptive changeset comments so people can more easily understand what you did.

Happy mapping!

Hello,
please make sure that you don't accidentally tag buildings with natural=tree. There have been several buildings with natural=tree tags. I fixed them all, don't worry.

Happy mapping!

Hello,
Thank you for adding all those details to the city center! Please make sure to tag treerow lines with natural=tree_row. Natural=tree is only used for single nodes, representing individual trees. So in this case, the nodes of the line should be tagged natural=tree, while the line itself should have natural=tree_row. I already fixed it here and near Dronning Louises Bro, where you added a tree row a few days ago, so just a heads up for future edits.

Thanks and happy mapping!

I already fixed it. I just wanted to tell you before you add more wrong dog permissions. Enjoy your walk!

Thank you for surveying this area! Please note that the correct tag for dog permissions is dog, not dogs.

Thanks and happy mapping!

There isn't a particularly good reason, other than that I used the stamdard add circle tool of my editor. I will simplify them in the future.

I guess I'd have to lobby the local government to build a road through that forest, splitting it in two parts!

Thank you for your comment, I will keep that in mind for future additions. I was going for the maximum to keep the number of members for the relation as low as possible (without having to sacrifice detail) because they easily get into the hunderets after adding all the clearings. But having a few more outer members will not make a big difference I suppose.

Thank you for adding the buildings! Please don't add any tags to the nodes, only the way when mapping buildings. The corners of the building don't need an extra "building=house" tag.

Thank you and happy mapping!

Hello Jake,

Thank you for adding all that info to the camping sites. Please note that the correct tag for dog is singular and not plural. See dog=*
I fixed this here and at the Lake Benmore site.
Thank you and happy mapping!
Jonas