MxxCon's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 153094708 | As documneted on tactile_paving=* "tactile_paving=yes" on a crossing way indicates a presence of tactile paving on the connecting KERBS, while the same tag on the crossing way indicates a presence of tactile surface on the way itself. Looking at the street-side imagery, I do not see any of the added crossings having any sort of tactile paving along the ways. Furthermore, a road's way is supposed to be mapped in the center of the physical road bed, not based on the paint or offset moving lanes. The way of E181 should be mapped straight, without that kink on the unmarked crossing.
|
|
| 152832212 | https://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/trafrule.pdf New York City Traffic Rules Section 4-04(c)(3), a pedestrian shall not: * Cross any road at an intersection except in a crosswalk.
|
|
| 152832212 | Actually that's exactly what directions should you to do! Crossing directions should not give you literally illegal instructions, ESPECIALLY for low vision and blind users! Routers should not be telling blind users to cross a road where drivers are not expecting to see pedestrians. |
|
| 152832212 | I removed it because in _my opinion_ unmarked crossing isn't indicating anything, because literally every single inch of a road between 2 sidewalks could be tagged as unmarked crossing. Plus it had tag "name=Crossing", which as documented on osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only shouldn't be used a made up descriptors of features.
|
|
| 152638859 | Hello.
|
|
| 152626535 | Hello.
|
|
| 152609458 | Hello.
Additionally, you created a closed way/1291940537, yet tagged it as a multipolygon.
Additionally, when mapping tennis courts, they should be mapped to the actual tennis court itself, not the surrounding area, which can be tagged separately. I corrected these issues for you.👍
|
|
| 152592808 | In this edit you also deleted highway=crossing tag. How come?
|
|
| 152592341 | Hello.
|
|
| 152585996 | Hello.
|
|
| 152565074 | Why did you delete crossing node on one of the ways here?
|
|
| 152564675 | Hello.
Also, please write meaningful changeset messages. Writing "." doesn't help others understand what you are editing.
|
|
| 152557106 | Hello.
|
|
| 152554851 | Also please write descriptive changeset comments. Leaving that field blank doesn't help other mappers understand what you are editing.
|
|
| 152554851 | Hello.
|
|
| 152545465 | Hello.
|
|
| 152521609 | Hello.
|
|
| 152520754 | In that case landuse=shrubs or landuse=grass sounds more appropriate. |
|
| 152520754 | Same question regarding this "garden" as the last one..
|
|
| 152520741 | Should this be leisure=garden as documented on leisure=garden or simply landuse=flowerbed or man_made=bioswale?
|