Changeset When Comment
187313199

Edit reviewed, it looks good.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/187313199

186464816

Hi, I saw that you requested a review on this edit. It's a huge improvement over what was there previously, but there's a few things to look out for:

1. The parking lot node is redundant; the area is already tagged as amenity=parking.
2. The largest area:highway=footway you tagged is actually a driveway. I highly recommend KyFromAbove's oblique imagery for getting a sense of things that might be hidden from top-down imagery, such as garage doors on a building.
3. Be careful with connecting areas to other features. I noticed that several areas aren't connected to adjacent areas; for example, the area:highway next to the playground isn't actually connected to the playground or shelter. This makes things more difficult to edit in the future.
4. When you have a situation like the park area where an area is surrounded by footpaths, leave a gap between areas and footpath ways. This is because the area of the park ends where the area of the footpath begins, not the footpath centerline. It shouldn't matter that much, and you'll find a lot of places that map it like you did, but it becomes annoying to disentangle to the two features if they ever need to be edited independently.
5. Are you sure the industrial area to the north is a scrap yard and not just industrial storage?

Overall, though, it's a solid first edit. If you have any more specific questions, feel free to ask.

165404113

Weird stuff happens. Thanks for fixing it!

165404113

I'm not seeing the Spring Grove bike lanes mapped separately. It appears to have been tagged correctly before. Am I misunderstanding something?