OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
144730826

Hi,
Please tag riding arenas differently from riding centres.
way/1228495467
way/1228495468
way/1228495469
are riding arenas and should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (the last one is not really an arena but just round pen, but they are usually also tagged like arenas). iD has a separate preset for riding arenas.

node/11392666605 is for the whole riding centre. This is ok, but there should be only one object (node or way) tagged with leisure=horse_riding for every riding centre.

Related information:
leisure=horse_riding
https://www.facebook.com/people/Sátorkő-Lovasiskola/100063673595807
relation/16784595

144697826

Oops, hadn't seen that this is in Belgium. So here is the English translation:

Hi,
way/1004981814 is not a riding facility. It's a horse walker, see animal=horse_walker . I have never seen anyone ride in a horse walker.

144697826

Hi,
way/1004981814 ist keine Reitanlage. Das ist eine Führanlage, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:animal=horse_walker . Habe noch nie jemanden in einer Führanlage reiten sehen.

144548531

Hi,
die Flächen, die du hier mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt hast, sind keine centres équestres. way/1227350454 ist vermutlich ein Reitplatz, der a
dann mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian zu taggen wäre (was du ja in ähnlichen Fällen bisher auch gemacht hast). way/1227350452 und way/1227350453 könnten Flächen für die Haltung von Pferden sein (Paddocks, landuse=animal_keeping).
Vgl. osm.wiki/FR:Équitation

144481556

Hi,
way/1227005185 looks like a riding arena. Riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and there is a preset in iD for riding arenas that does that.
You have tagged this area leisure=horse_riding which is for complete riding centres.
Please compare the following example and wiki page:

Riding arena:
way/1097626320

Wiki:
leisure=horse_riding

144440224

Hi,
way/1226699570 looks like a riding arena (and not like a riding centre), similar to way/1112674370. Riding arenas should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, see osm.wiki/FR:Tag:leisure=horse_riding

144387263

Hi,
It seems to be the riding centre describeb on this webpage:
https://www.visit-halkidiki.gr/portfolio-view/horseback-riding-school/
This is what could be tagged leisure=horse_riding

144387263

Hi,
The areas you have tagged leisure=horse_riding here are no riding centres, they are riding arenas or paddocks. Riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and in iD there is a preset that does that (in German: "Reitplatz").
The tag leisure=horse_riding is for complete riding centres and shall only be used once for every centre (because in reality this centre exits only once). Please compare the following information and example:

leisure=horse_riding

way/547296472

144371796

Hi,
way/1226206871 looks like a riding arena. Riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and there is a preset in iD that does that. Maybe there is something wrong with the et translation, I don't know.
You have tagged this area leisure=horse_riding which is for complete riding centres. Maybe there is such a riding centre of which the arena and the stable are part of, I don't know. Please see the following examples and wiki pages how it could be mapped:

Riding arena:
way/1097626320

Valgeranna tall:
way/815489443

Husön ratsastuskesku (Finnland):
way/1191597367

Wiki:
leisure=horse_riding

144306132

Hi,
I think the way you mapped the equestrian center is not ideal. You have mapped the outline of a building and tagged it with leisure=horse_riding. This tag should not be used for one building, but for the whole riding center. But each building should get a building tag, otherwise it won't render as a building. I would recommend mapping the equestrian center somehow like these:
way/624385595#map=18/52.63781/-7.21116&layers=P
way/554528453#map=17/53.33848/-6.38137&layers=P

See also:
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
building=riding_hall

144284337

Hi,
way/1225635179 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and in iD the is a separate preset for riding arenas which does that. Compare leisure=horse_riding

144239931

Hi, falls es sich bei way/1225398079 um einen Reitplatz handelt (was ich nach den Luftbildern stark vermute) wäre ein entsprechendes Tagging als osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz sinnvoller (analog zu changeset/123670098)

144246122

Hi,
way/1225427360 sieht auf dem Luftbild eher aus wie ein Reitplatz (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian); vgl. way/28114386 und osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding

144179986

Hi,
Why did you retag way/1115332843 ? Now there are 2 nested equestrian centres mepped (way/1115332843 inside of way/1115332846), which makes no sense.

144115011

Hi,
du hast hier alle möglichen Reitplätze und sogar eine Führanlage fälschlicherweise mit leisure=horse_riding ("Reitanlage") getaggt, nur die eigentliche Fläche der Reitanlage "Pferdetreffpunkt Abel" (way/123023994) hast du nicht damit getaggt. Vergleich das mal mit
way/806126313 (Reitverein Schwetzingen),
way/203861181 (Reitanlage Moser) oder
way/108685618 (Fießer-Hof)
und lies mal
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding
Kannst du deine Ergänzungen vielleicht noch weiter verbessern?

144041507

Yes. Search for "arena" and you can select the appropriate preset.

144048667

Hi,
way/1223759788 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre. Riding arenas should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (iD-preset "Horseback Riding / Rodeo Arena").

This is also the case for way/513969498 (jumping arena) and for way/136036265.

way/1223756381 looks like some paddocks perhaps, but not like a riding centre.

I don't know what way/1223763437 is, but for a riding centre it is too small. The tag leisure=horse_riding shall only be used for complete riding centres, see osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding
Example: way/533610195

144041507

No, the most fitting tag combination for an outdoor riding arena is leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, this is set by preset "Horseback Riding / Rodeo Arena". I noticed that, if you searched for "equestrian arena", this preset was not listed. This will hopefully be improved in the next release, see https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/pull/1055

143989754

Hi,
way/1223337119 is obviously not a racecourse, see https://www.facebook.com/KonjickiKlubClassic/ ; it should be tagged differently, see:
- osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
- way/856426537
- osm.org/changeset (similar problem)

143867832

Hi,
way/1222527768 does not look like a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding) and is too small for sport=horse_racing. I guess it is a riding arena which should be tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. In JOSM you can use the preset for sport=equestrian to set these tags.