ElliottPlack's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 42298129 | Hi Wolfgang! I did check for intersects when I was doing this work, using manually, but I may have missed some basins Phil has added due to the landuse tagging somehow. I think it is mostly good data, but if there are some areas needing clean up let me know. |
|
| 66917241 | Hey Phil! I havent seen you active much on OSM anymore but wondering if you have any local insight on the roads in the Red Run Stream Valley area now being completely closed to cars. Pleasant Valley seems to be. What do you know? |
|
| 99642644 | Hey there, thanks for adding this industrial area! For future landuse work like this, by local convention, please avoid snapping the landuse nodes to roads or railroads. Those areas could be better tagged with a railroad/highway landuse, or in this case, continue underneath the bridge. Cheers! -Elliott |
|
| 104263271 | Anastasia, great to hear it is fixed and thanks for the kind words! I will pay attention to those routing feature more, now that it is in heavy use by commercial entities like Lyft. How do you feel about Trunk roads? I have been pondering a Waze style systemic classification of routes based on function class. Professionally, I'm with Maryland Department of Transportation--we maintain the FC data for the state, on behalf of the FHWA, so I recognize how OSM roads are sometimes based on subjectivity rather than gov't data. This of course affects routing. Another thing you could look at for me is Boston Street in Canton (link at end). I saw either Lyft or Amazon made it a dual carriageway on a section where there is no median. I fixed it, but the turn lanes could use some updating. Could you make the updates and then I'll see your edit and know how to do that in the future. Thanks!! |
|
| 104263271 | Alright, I fixed the relation by simplifying with just this way joining the parts that make up the boundary. Please confirm this way is not routable by Lyft: way/949794714 |
|
| 104263271 | Hey there! I love to see these Lyft edits to the map, as a former Lyft driver and big OSM advocate. Thank you for the work. Two things: 1, I'm working on these CDP boundaries and this one is agreeably messed up. The standard is to connect non-intersecting roads that make up a boundary with an untagged way that is part of the relation. This one is set to intersect leading to impossible turns. I will attempt to fix in moment, but please let me know if it is still broken. That leads to section 2: If there is anyway I can help Lyft in making edits, let me know (in general). Lane counts, restrictions, stuff like that, tell me what is useful to add/maintain? I think it is important to make the roads more logical and useful for routing! |
|
| 98150824 | Hey Duga, I've been working on updating the CDP boundaries from 2000 version to 2020 so I'm gradually getting rid of these older boundary lines. There might be some broken in the interim, not to worry though, they'll all be handled. |
|
| 105384929 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105450012 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105450350 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105450380 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105450580 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105450746 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105453627 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105453662 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105453809 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 105455515 | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
|
| 97331413 | Here we go again with the massive cleanup! Why did you remove buildings that were recently constructed? |
|
| 104753007 | Some of the deletions here were for newly constructed roads. Did you check the history before relying on potentially dated imagery? |
|
| 104789797 | Perhaps you only meant to delete some buildings but it is clear in the dataset that the DWG posted in your block that the entire site was removed. Did you see that link? |