DaveF's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 183291772 | There's a lot of crap written in the wiki.
"it is highly likely that the pedestrian will want to cross" is pure subjectivity. No facts, No evidence. Once again contributors are adding fantasy data to appease lazy, incompetent software writers. As I previously pointed out, in Britain pedestrians can cross anywhere. That would mean you'll have to add crossings ever 100mm. You misunderstand the purpose of routers. They *don't* dictate where someone /has/ to walk, merely suggest the direction to take. They do *not* prevent anyone from crossing the streets where they wish. Subjectivity & guesswork have no place in OSM. |
|
| 183291772 | There is no such thing as jaywalking in the UK. Pedestrians can cross anywhere. You should only map actual physical objects, not your best guess of a situation. Please don;t tag inaccurately for routers. |
|
| 183295100 | It doesn't make it clearer as the commercial area does no extend to the centre of the roads. It makes it more inaccurate. This is poor mapping. |
|
| 183756495 | https://maps.app.goo.gl/hwfrjfYw6CyvgWy78 is this path not in use any more? |
|
| 183755881 | Hi
having a record of what they were is a useful reference if they reopen in the future. |
|
| 183291772 | There is no crossing here
|
|
| 183284263 | This is circular:
|
|
| 183291772 | There is no crossing here: node/25723436 Why have you detached this crossing from the footways
Why have you created a duplicating crossing:
|
|
| 183295100 | Hi
If the polygon has tagged nodes (such as barriers) they are also associated with the ways. |
|
| 182939079 | way/744109396/#map=19/51.413115/-0.430784
|
|
| 182576415 | Placing it on top of station buildings clashes with that building's name label. |
|
| 182303816 | Please do not remove tags that have value for validation checks (disused:fhrs:id). |
|
| 181342465 | Hi
|
|
| 181728087 | You've made this just as bad by moving the road to an inaccurate location instead of moving the inaccurately placed house.
|
|
| 181525769 | Does he have aliases as there seems to be a few 'contributors' who have the same style of editing (although this maybe the editor inducing it. I've always thought iD did more harm than good.) |
|
| 181525769 | Why have you erroneously amended data for this station:
Where did you get the idea it was part of the Elizabeth Line? |
|
| 180969272 | What trains are stopping there? I thought it was just trams. |
|
| 180850253 | As the only reason platforms exist is for the public to walk on them a highway=foot is moot.
|
|
| 180649262 | Please provide more detailed changeset comments. What erroneous dataset are you using for these railway station amendments? node/5206774617
|
|
| 180683098 | way/1494652558
|