Changeset When Comment
111518275

Which renderer are you using that is so incredibly broken that it ignores some building types?

The correct thing to do is to fix the renderer, not break the map.

111518275

Is there a reason why you think that Maplewood Gardens, The Academy, Altura, and The Highline shouldn't be apartment buildings, or is it just that RapID is allergic to classifying building types?

111518010

You're clearly not spending enough, if any, time reviewing things. One of the "buildings" in this changeset is a travel trailer, and another only vaguely resembles the actual structure on the ground.

Please stop.

111516961

Please stop adding low-quality scribbles to the map.

111516159

Please don't. We're supposed to be getting a much better set of building outlines to import from in the near future.

110887834

What sort of a business is a "Chris O'Doherty - Windermere"? It's useful to tag that so people can find it when searching by type, not just when searching by name.

110258620

It would be nice if you explained *why* you're changing the road classification. The last person to do so did.

109971441

You've changed the official name of the United States to "ur=ریاست ہائے متحدہ". Do you plan to fix this?

108863021

What sort of a thing is "Pandora"? I'm pretty sure that "park" isn't the correct tag for it.

108518791

I've noticed a few errors in this changeset:

* Where southbound Ash Street divides in two, both sides of the split are roads, and both of them go by the name "Ash Street".
* There's a similar issue where southbound Maple Street comes off the bridge: both pieces prior to the merge are roads known as "Maple Street".
* 4th Avenue west of Maple isn't an arterial: the speed limit is 25 mph and cross streets don't have stop signs. This means it should be tagged as "unclassified", not "tertiary".

I'm also not sure the classification of Sprague Way is correct: yes, it's the primary connection between two major streets, but it is not itself a major street.

107407270

Really damn minor state route.

107283749

You added the description "Adequate gravel Equestrian Trailer parking" to a number of things that don't look much like parking lots. Was this a mistake?

105647209

When you merged the road, you also tagged the whole thing as a bridge, and dropped the units on the speed limit (so it's now marked as 35 km/h rather than 35 mph). I've fixed it, but please be more careful in the future.

105448474

Your aim seems to be a bit off: you renamed Silver Creek as "South 3rd Street".

104146594

Please don't use Esri Clarity when deciding if something still exists or not -- it's the oldest available imagery. Relying on it can cause you to delete driveways that were recently constructed, like you did in Deer Park.

102056770

You've drawn the Trout Creek NRT as overlapping the Hope Valley road. Do the two share a route?

103731700

Looks good to me.

103439756

"Some very small mistakes" is understating it. In my experience with RapiD, it's got about a 10% error in the sort of area you've been mapping -- one building detection out of every ten is bad.

103439756

Please pay more attention to what RapiD is telling you to do: in three cases, you've mapped multiple buildings as one, and in one case, you've mapped two buildings as attached when they're actually separate.

103212218

The "DIY Store" tag is meant for places like Home Depot. Horizon Distributors looks like it might be a "Trade Shop", while I don't know how to tag a heavy-equipment dealer like Vermeer Rocky Mountain.