9_tab's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 185005351 | ça serait pratique préciser la région ou le pays concerné dans le résumé. |
|
| 184225547 | Also, ground survey didn't find this. |
|
| 184515411 | @Sebasawk: even if it was reverted, can we get the reasoning behind this change? I noticed a series of similar changesets. None seem to explain why. I'd think of driveways as access roads, but maybe you read a difference in the definition, please explain. If you stopped working on this, can you ask somebody else from your employer, TomTom, to follow-up on this question? |
|
| 184939261 | ||
| 184794688 | voir changeset/184476050 |
|
| 184803847 | voir changeset/184476050 |
|
| 184697070 | Noted. Thanks. |
|
| 184699595 | Actually, I didn't. I looked at their aerial imagery, just to notice that the resolution seems to be 20th century-like. The address nodes were already present on the Map, but placed outside the structure. So I moved them into it, leaving it to the local mapper to improve it further. |
|
| 184225547 | amenity=doctors is generally used for physicians. Robin Gervais is not licensed to practice in Switzerland. |
|
| 184477954 | Maybe addr:housenumber=* ? Interestingly, these are already present, but with different values. Sample: way/1531647846 has 61 node/12273172169 has 31 |
|
| 184256756 | Indirectly, the URLs provide a reference for the entire feature, not just its names. This is not inconsistent with our key definition at url=* . Providing a reference is not the same as sourcing and generally implies multiple resources. If you are worried about long-term retrieval, there is the Internet Archive. Is there a single resource you have in mind from which you had wanted to source and create this? Sorry if I got ahead of you. |
|
| 184515411 | Which part of the definition are you referring to? The picture illustrating the article might even look like the manor on that property. |
|
| 182842275 | The value for the key addr:country=* would generally be osm.wiki/Tag%3Aaddr%3Acountry%3DCO |
|
| 184102102 | The value for addr:country=* would generally be addr:country=IT |
|
| 184515411 | What's the reasoning behind the removal of service=driveway from these access roads? |
|
| 183691922 | I created it directly at node/13961838365 |
|
| 184256756 | I added the URLs to provide verifyability for how this exclave is named. There is no official website and the region is not present in swissNAMES3D, so I used several relevant pages that document those naming variants, including different names across Buchberg's website. They provide long-term, checkable references. relation/1687206 was created by another mapper. I'm open to adjusting the tagging approach to better match OSM guidance for storing multiple references. |
|
| 184476050 | Pour ce type de modification récurrente, serait-ce possible d'ajouter au résumé le/les pays concernés (la France, j'imagine) ? Ou de limiter l'étendue géographique des changeset ? |
|
| 183691922 | Yes, that helps, thanks. On a separate node (POI) for you, that URL could be in url=* . To indicate that its within the centre, maybe
This should provide a minium level of verifiability and could work for similar POIs. BTW, in my view, you could include your personal name in name=* . There is also contact:facebook=* contact:instagram=* contact:linkedin=* . Personally, I'd avoid including an email, but it's up to you. Notice: This comment may be spell-checked and proofread with various tools. It does reflect the views of myself or those mentioned. |
|
| 174297605 | node/13285536907 is the same as node/12124115850 |