Thanks for your help.

The tool and the libraries it calls get gradually improved based on mapper feedback. (I'm waiting for an update of a library that should make an entry in OW disappear and I asked for LI to be included.). A new function now updates the lists (when logged in).

This can explain some of the older entries, also I got the impression you had omitted defibrillators in GR.

Personally, I sometimes fix an issue with a string and notice the next day that there was (also) some other. I found the two parts of each report take some time to get used to navigate.

There is some benefit in enabling each mapper to do this themselves. Occasionally a suggestion is incorrect and depending on your criteria you may want to do other checks first.

The review of defibrillators uncovered the problem with levels, the weekend issue, and its use of quoted text in strings (apparently limited to CH). If you have a reliable bot available, you could try to work with that instead.

Update: organicmaps has problems handling "PH" in opening_hours strings, see https://github.com/organicmaps/organicmaps/issues/1575 as it was pointed out in
https://c.osm.org/t//146392/6

If it's EGID, ideally it's on the building. As I didn't hear from you, I had to start the poll. The poll runs for about 2 weeks. Let's see where it goes.

relation/1113133/history/6 has another value in route=* . I was trying to find a good sample.

Please see https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/poll-key-for-egid-gwr-tags/146319

Your edit removes "PH", nothing else changed. You can verify opening_hours strings with https://openingh.openstreetmap.de/evaluation_tool/

It doesn't say anything about being closed on PH.

what's the basis for this change?

In the meantime the lists at https://opening-hours.pages.dev/schweiz-suisse-svizzera-svizra/ have been updated. You might want to revisit them. In the list, some are not labelled "defibrillator", but with whatever the mapper added as name. So you might want to look for the defibrillator icon instead.

I was hoping the tool could be made to solve some of the issues with your data mentioned at (b) and (c) in https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/announcing-an-opening-
hours-validator/145214/84 , but the developer tells me this is a localized issue (thus I assume limited to your data).

For a fully unrelated issue that came up during these checks, see changeset/157117341 If you need help solving this, let me know.

what's the operator in node/7200788995/history/1 ?

In edits like way/47405983/history/3 "ref:gwrid" is added. If it's the same, maybe we would want to change this to ref:EGID=* . The key has the advantage being described on the wiki (recently, years after your mapping). "ref:CH:egid" would be a more standardized format. In GWR, it's named EGID, but GWR uses a few other identifiers. All uses of ref:gwrid seem to be around here.

J'en ai fait, https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/2ukF n'en trouve plus.

That's bad. A simple solution could be to block edits with "(no comment)" as summary

I understand your point of view, but the mappers whose contributions you deleted saw that differently.

In the future, please just leave them in.

I wonder if the user even noticed that they were blocked. If they didn't even notice they were publishing here, it's a problem. A followup with the app developer might help avoid such cases in the future.

Pas de souci. Je peux le faire, si ça aide.

What was incorrect about the wiki links?

why the mass deletion of tags?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/186805117

thanks. will fix.

Minor detail: the value for the key addr:country=* is just the country code, not the spelled out name.

Thus it would be
addr:country=ID
instead of
addr:country=Indonesia