OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
157433739

Hi,
This change is incorrect, the town is spelt "Fleur-de-lis"
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/157433739

157352361

Hello Darklot, and welcome to OSM.

although this changeset does not appear malicious overall, it has quite a few bad and dubious changes. In Llanbradoch, you deleted a service road that shouldn't have been deleted and made a bit of a mess out of the landuse=residential area. In Fleur-De-Lis you connected St Deinois Close to St Davids Rd when it shouldn't be. you also added a view point and a named rock to Rhymney river, nether of which I believe exist. For these reasons and the fact you've got a history of adding fictious data, I'll be reverting this changeset. If this is a genuine attempt at making improvements to OSM, I encourage you to make smaller changes to begin with until you get the hang of editing so that your changes can be more selectively critiqued. Please feel free to ask any questions you may have,
Kind regards,
Kits.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/157352361

157249571

Hi eajones,
you might want to check out Tredegar and Rhymney gold course. osm.org/#map=17/51.750175/-3.263594 it has already been mapped to a relatively high standard so it may be useful as a reference.

157348133

Correction on the revert message, this one was reverted because all that was changed was a solar panel was moved from a roof into a road.

157348133

Reverting changeset due to fictitious roads or names being added

changeset/157351570

157347864

Reverting changeset due to fictitious roads or names being added

changeset/157351570

157229538

Reverting changeset due to fictitious roads or names being added

changeset/157351570

157229498

Reverting changeset due to fictitious roads or names being added

changeset/157351570

157229338

Reverting changeset due to fictitious roads or names being added

changeset/157351570

156838633

Hello Tapa,
In all your recent changesets you've been adding blank areas instead of buildings. To change this, select an area in the editor then click on "Area" button in the top left and then search for "Building", this will then change the blank area into a generic building. Please note that untagged areas don't get rendered to the map but buildings do. You have also created a few overlapping areas in some places like here: osm.org/edit?editor=id&#map=20/2.6924346/-73.1903277
please fix this before continuing.

Kind regards,
Kits
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/156838633

156816387

Hi RunEveryStreet,
Welcome to OSM. I believe you have made a small mistake here, max height should be added to the road that is affected not to the road on the bridge. I've fixed this now.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/156816387

156728477

osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property osm.wiki/Why_can%27t_I_delete_this_trail%3F

156728477

Reverted as OSM is built on public information such as imagery as such details can't be removed simply by request.

changeset/156746836

156728446

Reverted as OSM is built on public information such as imagery as such details can't be removed simply by request.

changeset/156746836

156541323

reverted changesets 156541289, 156541323 due to mass deletion without description and failed to respond to comments.

changeset/156746040

156541289

reverted changesets 156541289, 156541323 due to mass deletion without description and failed to respond to comments.

changeset/156746040

156662962

I will accept there is a argument for meadows here, I wasn't aware that meadows was also used for hay although I question how well that tagging will work since a farmer may choose grain over hay on a particular year but that's not a conversation for here. As for way/131600335, yes you did not created it but you did change it from landuse=farmland to landuse=grass in this changeset. landuse=grass is not correct here and should be changed.

156707943

High there Canalsman,
Just let you know you can make multiple changes for per each changeset. it is good practice to group related changes together into few changesets.
Kind regards,
Kits
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/156707943

156662962

Hi, I dont think these changes are correct, most of these fields appear to be growing fields from imergery so should be tagged landuse=farmland not meadows. also landuse=grass is used wrong on way/131600335#map=15/51.95377/-3.88672. landuse=grass is used for managed areas of grass like a lawn. from imagery this area appears to be a mix of farmland and meadows.

156522727

personally I think there is a enough evidence from imagery that this should be replaced with a mini-roundabout node as there is no physical island as its just painted on.