Hi Jez,

you added 6 trees with height=stump,
would you agree to remove the height and change them to natural=tree_stump?

thanks and good mapping :)

Hallo srmac,

node/8914825627/history

this tree has an incorrect value, do you know the real one?

thanks and good mapping :)

Hi seanthlin,

node/9060342885/history

this tree have a incorrect height, do you know what's the real one?

thanks and good mapping :)

Hi Matthew,

node/8753912465/history

this tree (and the one nearby) seem to have a wrong height, do you know what's the real value?

thanks and good mapping

Hi Grenzer,

node/8742712067

this tree seems to have a wrong height. Do you know what's the real one?

Thanks and good mapping

Hi assar, thanks for the edits,

I saw there are 5450 trees with height="3 - 5". The wiki says that height should be a number, not a range. Would you agree in moving this value to est_height=*?

thanks and good mapping :)

Hi Plaintelive, I saw you deleted some trees in Bologna and replaced them with a tree row. Singular trees can be part of a tree row ("This approach can also be combined with individually mapped trees for further details."), in my opinion this should be preferred so no detail is lost, such as the number of trees. Also people could contribute adding the circumference for every single tree ecc.

But this is my opninion, thanks for the edits and good mapping!

L'elenco fatto sopra è un'estrazione .csv fatta con Overpass di tutti i valori ancora presenti nel database.

Io sarei per tenerli, alcuni si possono fixare utilizzando species:it come riferimento, per quelli rimanenti si può sempre cancellare la sigla

Hola Abimelec, gracias por tus ediciones y ¡bienvenido a OSM!

node/11785264999/history

Me di cuenta de este árbol, está mapeado dentro de un edificio, ¿es correcto? También tenga en cuenta que la unidad estándar es metros, por lo que circumference=162 significa una circunferencia de 162 metros. Esto no es probable, tal vez debería ser fijado con circumference=1.62

buen mapping :)

Traducción realizada con DeepL.com

Hi Abimelec, thanks for your edits and welcome to OSM!

node/11785264999/history

I noticed this tree, is mapped inside a building, is it correct? Also please notice that the standard unit is meters, so circumference=162 means a circumference of 162 meters. This isn't likely, maybe it should be fixed with circumference=1.62

good mapping :)

>> Should I map them in another way?

Oh, I don't know really. I wasn't just sure that it was a typo or something different. Based on what you said the value just missed a p, shee(p)fold. Thanks for the quick reply and good mapping!

Hi Abn_976,

what's the meaning of leaf_cycle=urban?

quelle est la signification de leaf_cycle=urban ?

Ciao NonnEmilia,

so che sono 10 anni fa, ma ho notato che molte specie di alberi hanno ancora una sigla come value: Jr, Fc, Pa, Ps, Ln, Sa, Sj, Jn, Oc, Pu, Rb, Fs, Sd, Rc, Mc, Si, St, Sc, Pon, Moa, Pr1, Pra, Qui, Prp, Tg4, Mg1, Pot, Quc, Li1, Fro, Pna, Poc, Pni, Mlf, Lai, Prs, Pny, Tax, Sni, Pyc, Koe, Tg3, Lir, Sau, Hib, Mel, Sab, Pnr, Prl, Sse, Mld, Prd, Pr6, Pfr, Li7, Ole, Mlp, Mls, Pai, Pap, Qup, For, Neo, Pr5, Mes, Pr8, Prv, Mg4, Pau, El1, Ker, Rph, Glt, Qus, Lid, Fry, Pma, Prc, Qua, Gim, Pte, Liq, Rac, Pa2, Os1, Rhs, Ste, Syr, Li6, Sam, Tdi, Li4, Sxt, Mlc, Ila, Pns, Tg2, Lo1, Wis, Mop, Juc, Saf, Li2, Skj, El4, Sgi, Plu, Pr7, Pnm, Sae, Sap, Sar, Pys, Qcr, Fam, Quf, Pos, Qtp, Qca, Sat, Sav, Yuc, Qurb, Moa1, Qur1, Poex, Pych, Poa1, Ros1, Glt1, Soj1, Pfr1, Sach, Pla1, Sni1, Lide, Prse, Tax2

Tu per caso sai dove trovare (se esiste) o hai ancora una tabella con le corrispondenze?

grazie e buon mapping

Hi Janani,

https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/597573939

building="Grocery Store" is not the correct way to map a grocery store. You should add shop=grocery or shop=supermarket or shop=convenience.

If the building was built as a grocery store I guess building=retail would fit

Hola Jordi!

way/1030886011/history

before fixing it, is this building value (sheefold) a typo for sheepfold?

Thanks and good mapping

Here: https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=464740757970461&focus=photo

in this location you mapped a pond and a wetland. Sure, I guess the sprinklers make the land wet and some puddle are visible, but I would't call them a pond and a wetland.

and please, use meaningful changeset comments, such as "added a coastline". "dream" is not a good changeset comment, see: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Hi Helcherd,

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=464108644650925&lat=25.76777036&lng=-100.21110632&z=17&focus=photo

this doesn't look like a beach. Could you provide a better source for your edit?

Also, why did you map a coastline just nearby?: way/1277750350/history/1

being the latin translation is not enough, it needs to be a documented taxonomical rank. Based on Wikipedia (https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grass) grass is defined as the Poaceae family. So we could change this tag with either taxon=Poaceae or taxon:family=Poaceae