Hi Landry GAIFFE,

seems like all the imported trees have incorrect circumference=* values. Such as node/9052696963/history with circumference=55. The world record is 43m, so it's likely that the values you imported are in centimeters.

They should all be fixed with circumference=55 cm or circumference=0.55

Also the standard for species is to add the complete name. Example species=Populus nigra instead of species=nigra

*this tree: node/3116858173/history

I just noticed that all these circumference are to be fixed. For istance, this tree has circumference=51 (with the standard unit of measur for this tag being meters), but the greates circumference in the world is 43 meters.

All this imported trees should be fixed adding "cm" at the end of them or converting them to meters such circumference=0.51 instead of circumference=51

I counted at least 12444 trees with values >43 in Bruxelles, which can't be.

Mi ha tradito l'ora tarda e la stanchezza, grazie per la correzione!

Hm, I read now in the last block: "20 february 2024: This block is now lifted under the condition that errors are restored!"

So I guess the errors aren't restored yet based on what you told me.

Hi CatRBLX,

what's the source of this geometry?
way/1240875738/history

In the imagery you used, Bing Maps Aerial, no building is visible.

I once used fee=included for a similar case. I remember I raised this problem here: https://t.me/OpenStreetMapOrg/96365

Seems like you are just "translating" russian names to ukrainian names without any kind of check?
In such case could you discuss these kind of edits with the Italian community (as per guidelines osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct)?

What's the source of these edits? It doesn't seem like they are survey and local knowledge as stated in the changeset metadata.

Also, let's take an example: node/4690647982
This cafe is called "Bar Mary" and you added the ukrainian name "Слов'янський", which Google translates as "Slavic". What's the meaning of this edit?

Here:
relation/14143259
"Isola delle femmine" has the ukrainian name "Ізола-делле-Фемміне", which doesn't seem ukrainian at all, just the same italian name written in cyrillic ecc.ecc.

Hi Apay00,

as another user pointed out 3 months ago, could you use better changeset comments? See: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Hi Fares, thanks for your edits. I fixed some problems, please see: https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/1246156302

As you can see, wikimedia_commons=* and mapillary=* have a syntax to be followed. start_date=* uses the YY-MM-DD syntax.

Also please use good changeset comments, there's no need to write them in english, you can use arabic if you are more confident with it.

Thanks and good mapping.

------------------------------

مترجمة مع DeepL:

مرحبًا فارس، شكرًا على تعديلاتك. لقد أصلحت بعض المشاكل، يرجى الاطلاع على: https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/1246156302

كما ترى، wikimedia_commons=* و mapillary=* لها بناء جملة يجب اتباعه. start_date=* يستخدم بناء الجملة YY-MM-DD.

يرجى أيضًا استخدام تعليقات مجموعة التغييرات الجيدة، لا داعي لكتابتها باللغة الإنجليزية، يمكنك استخدام اللغة العربية إذا كنت أكثر ثقة بها.

شكراً وتخطيط جيد.

Hi tg4567,

node/10702895856/history

the wikimedia_commons category you added here was since deleted. Do you have the local knowledge to fix it? I tried taking a look but the wiki tags are about a M3 station, but the landuse is called M11, so I'm confused.

Same problem with:
1. node/11157685025/history
2. node/11157685026/history

they link the same category which was since deleted

thank you and good mapping :)

Ciao Simone, che tipo di attrazioni turistiche sono "Asini volanti kuass al paradiss" e "Fungaia"?

Ciao crys76,

questi nomi sono nomi utilizzati dai biker? "Mezze Penne al Burro" e "Arrideli" non sembrano proprio nomi ufficiali. In questo caso non va utilizzato il tag name=* ma il tag mtb:name=*.

A comment could have been "Added kannada name to Danube".

I think adding it to the relation was enough tho, that's it's usefulness, to not repeat common tags on every way part of the relation ("Tags describing the waterway as a whole should go only on the relation (e.g. wikidata=*, destination=*, ...).").

Hi Allouche,

please notice that start_date=* has a syntax to be followed as wiki. So values such as "=1956 par le curé Lucien Foucher" and "=2005 par le Président Omar Bongo Ondimba avec Dominique Auroy" should be fixed.

Also are names supposed to be uppercase? e.g why "Domaine d'ASSIAMI" and not "Domaine d'Assiami", "Viticulture du HAUT-OGOOUE" and not "Haut-Ogooue", "Camp DILO" and not "Camp Dilo" ecc.ecc.?

Hi IbrahimTh,

wikimedia_commons=* as a syntax to be followed as wiki
e.g. wikimedia_commons=Wadi Arus should be wikimedia_commons=Category:Wadi Arus ecc.

Hi DMNorby,

please be careful, you added the building=* tag as well even if it's not a building. I fixed it

good mapping

Hi EinEngener,

seems like you used webiste=* instead of wikimedia_commons=* on some elements by mistake, see: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1Jiw
also the value is repeated in image.

I would fix website=* with wikimedia_commons=* using the proper syntax as wiki and delete image=* when duplicated. What do you think about it?

@joost
for the record, the caravan site was added by another user: changeset/132305616